This short e-booklet is a criticism of the belief in
the Rapture, and by implication also of premillennialism. The author is a
member of the Orthodox Church in America, and the criticism is therefore
offered from an Eastern Orthodox perspective. John Peck and Barnabas Powell
argues that neither the Bible, the Nicene Creed nor the Church Fathers mention
the Rapture. Nobody believed in such a thing until the 19th century. Therefore,
the belief quite simply must be wrong. While the authors are probably right
that Paul didn't teach a “secret Rapture” of the kind popularized by modern
Protestant fundamentalism, they runs into other problems. Thus, they quote the
Church Father Irenaeus and clearly regard him as a legitimate source of
authority. Yet, Irenaeus believed in the millennium, a viewpoint Peck and Powell
regard as heretical! Here we see the problem with the Orthodox view: there
simply isn't a united “tradition” to begin with. And since there isn't, it's
not *completely* out of the question that something forgotten for centuries
might have been rediscovered by 1812… That being said, I nevertheless give this
short exposition three stars, since it gives a good overview of what I take is
the official Orthodox position on the matter.
No comments:
Post a Comment