A review of "Washington´s Masonic Correspondence in the Library of Congress"
The first U.S. president, George Washington, was a
Freemason. In and of itself, this is unremarkable. Masonry was popular during
the period in question, and many illustrious persons were members of the Craft.
In Sweden, King Gustavus III, his African servant Badin, and his assassin
Anckarström were all Masons! Politically, many Masons supported the
Enlightenment, but that's where their fraternity ends, Masons being about as
split as Christians or Muslims on the issues of the day.
However, due to the secretive nature of Freemasonry, Masons were often accused
of foul play by conspiracy theorists already during Washington's lifetime, and
the allegations haven't abated since. In the United States, there has even been
an Anti-Masonic Party (directed against President Andrew Jackson). Since many
conspiracy theorists simultaneously support Washington and the Founding
Fathers, the president's Masonic involvement has become something of a
liability, Anti-Masons often trying to prove that he really wasn't a Mason after
all. More radical conspiracists accept that the first president was a Free
Mason, and therefore refuse to support him.
This is a reprint of a book published in 1915, which contains the preserved
correspondence pertaining to Freemasonry between George Washington and various
Masonic bodies. Some of the material can be found in Washington's papers in the
Library of Congress, other comes from Masonic archives. I think it proves
conclusively that Washington was a Mason. Indeed, I don't think any historian
seriously doubts this. Washington was a member of the Alexandria Lodge in
Pennsylvania, which later transferred its allegiance to Virginia. Washington
also attended meetings of other Masonic lodges. At two occasions, Washington
professed his membership of the Order in public: during a procession organized
by the Grand Lodge of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia in 1778, and during the
laying of the foundation stone to the Capitol in Washington City in 1793. At
the latter occasion, Washington wore a Masonic apron he had received as a gift
from Lafayette.
Those who deny Washington's Masonry usually point to his correspondence with
one G W Snyder, a preacher who had sent the General a copy of John Robinson's
conspiracist book about the Illuminati. Snyder was under the erroneous
impression (quite wide-spread at the time) that Washington was the actual Grand
Master of all U.S. Masons, and therefore called on him to purge the Illuminati
and “Jacobins” from the ranks of Masonry. In response, Washington correctly
denied being the Grand Master, but then proceeded to deny all other involvement
in Masonic lodges: “The fact is, I preside over none nor have I been in one,
more than once or twice, within the last thirty years.” This was obviously a
white lie, perhaps made necessary by the vociferous anti-Masonic agitation of
Snyder and his associates.
Interestingly, Washington then proceeded to defend the Craft from any
accusations of conspiracy. In his first letter to Snyder, he said: “I believe
nothwithstanding, that none of the Lodges in this Country are contaminated with
the principles ascribed to the society of the Illuminati”. In his second
letter, the Founding Father added: "It was not my intention to doubt that,
the doctrines of the Illuminati, and principles of Jacobism [sic] had not
spread in the United States. On the contrary, no one is more fully satisfied of
this fact that I am. The idea I meant to convey, was, that I did not believe
that the Lodges of Free Masons in this Country had, as Societies, endeavoured
to propagate the diabolical tenets of the first, or the pernicious principles
of the latter, (if they are susceptible of separation) That individuals of them
may have done it, or that the founder, or instrument employed to found the
Democratic Societies in the United States, may have had these objects, and
actually had a separation of the people from their Government in view, is too
evident to be questioned.”
In a letter to the Grand Lodge of Maryland, Washington originally wanted to
include a polemic against Snyder, but for some reason deleted its second
sentence before the letter was sent. The polemic reads: “So far as I am
acquainted with the principles & Doctrines of Free Masonry, I conceive it
to be founded in benevolence and to be exercised only for the good of mankind.
If it has been a Cloak to promote improper or nefarious objects, it is a
melancholly proof that in unworthy hands, the best institutions may be made use
of to promote the worst designs.”
The rest of Washington's Masonic correspondence included in this volume is of
much less interest, and essentially consists of florid greetings from various
Masonic bodies, and Washington's somewhat shorter replies. Two items do stand
out, however. During the Revolutionary War, two American agents in France sent
the Commander in Chief a Masonic apron made by nuns at a convent in Nantes! In
1790, Washington attended a Masonic meeting in a Jewish synagogue in Rhode
Island, the state Grand Lodge being presided over by Moses Seixas, a successful
Sephardic merchant and banker. No big deal either, unless you are a hopeless
anti-Semite who believes in a grand American-Masonic-Jewish conspiracy!
Since this is a rather unusual work, perhaps I'm permitted to point out that it
exists in several reprint editions, and that it's also available free on the
web.