If you know, you know. Muh-hah-hah-hah!
How long does it take for a domesticated species of plant to turn wild again? Does this have any bearing on the question of when agriculture began?
Excellent and deep question — let’s tackle it in two parts:
🌱 1. How long does it take for a domesticated plant species to “turn wild” again?
This process is called feralization — when a domesticated species reverts to a wild or semi-wild state after escaping cultivation or human management.
⏳ How fast can it happen?
-
In some cases, feralization can begin within a few generations (e.g., 5–50 years), especially in annual plants that reproduce quickly.
-
Traits that are lost or reduced during domestication — like seed shattering, seed dormancy, or thorn production — can re-evolve under natural selection if beneficial in the wild.
-
Full reversion to a wild-type genome is rare, but feral plants often show:
-
Increased seed dispersal
-
Decreased yield
-
Resumption of natural defenses (e.g., toxins or spines)
-
📌 Example: Weedy rice (Oryza sativa f. spontanea), which evolved from domesticated rice and re-developed wild traits in only a few centuries (possibly faster in some regions).
📜 2. Does this affect how we date the beginning of agriculture?
Yes — feralization complicates the archaeological record of agriculture in important ways:
🧭 Here's how:
-
Early farming was likely intermittent, small-scale, and low-intensity.
-
If agriculture was abandoned for even a few decades or centuries, domesticated crops could go feral and vanish from the landscape and archaeological visibility.
-
This means that early domestication events could have occurred thousands of years before the earliest definitive archaeological evidence.
🔄 Agriculture as a long process:
-
Modern archaeology sees domestication as a gradual, multi-generational process, not a single moment.
-
Some species show pre-domestication cultivation — early humans planted them before the genetic signs of full domestication appear.
-
If early farming societies collapsed or moved, their plants may have reverted — making it seem like agriculture started “later” than it actually did.
🧬 Genetic evidence shows that domestication traits (like non-shattering ears in wheat or barley) accumulated slowly, and can be lost under feral conditions.
🧾 Summary
✅ Domesticated plants can revert toward wild forms surprisingly quickly (within decades to centuries), depending on the species and environment.
🧠 This means that early, failed, or abandoned attempts at agriculture may have left no clear trace in the archaeological record.
📆 As a result, the true origins of agriculture may be older and more complex than previously thought, with cycles of cultivation, abandonment, and re-domestication.
Would you like examples of specific plants (like wheat, barley, or maize) and how quickly they can feralize or re-domesticate?
Great — let’s explore how wheat, barley, maize, and rice behave when feralized (i.e., revert from domestication) or re-domesticated, and what that tells us about the timing and complexity of agriculture’s origins.
🌾 1. Wheat (Triticum spp.)
🧬 Domesticated Traits:
-
Non-shattering spikelets (seeds stay on the stalk, making harvesting easier)
-
Larger grains
-
Softer seed coats
🔄 Feralization/Reversion:
-
Under wild conditions, non-shattering becomes a disadvantage (seeds don’t disperse).
-
Studies show that feral wheat lines can evolve partial shattering again within ~20–50 generations (500–1,000 years).
-
However, wheat is less weedy and does not easily naturalize without human help.
🧠 Implication:
Wheat domestication was slow, taking 1,000–2,000+ years, and could reverse partially if early agriculture was abandoned.
🌾 2. Barley (Hordeum vulgare)
🧬 Domesticated Traits:
-
Like wheat: non-shattering spikes, larger grains
-
Shorter dormancy, more uniform germination
🔄 Feralization:
-
Weedy barley populations (H. vulgare f. spontaneum) are common near fields.
-
Barley can hybridize with wild relatives, rapidly reintroducing wild traits like:
-
Seed dormancy
-
Rough awns (barbs)
-
Shattering
-
📌 Some barley reverts to near-wild form within <500 years when left uncultivated.
🧠 Implication:
Barley is more plastic than wheat, showing frequent gene flow with wild forms. This makes archaeological dating of “fully domesticated” barley complicated.
🌽 3. Maize (Zea mays)
🧬 Domesticated Traits:
-
Derived from teosinte (wild grass from Mexico)
-
Maize has:
-
Larger cobs
-
Multiple rows of kernels
-
Non-shattering seeds (fully dependent on humans to spread)
-
🔄 Feralization:
-
Maize is highly domesticated and does not easily revert.
-
However, teosinte-maize hybrids can arise spontaneously if maize is grown near wild relatives.
-
Some “wild maize” types in Mexico are likely re-wilded hybrids, but they don’t fully return to teosinte.
🧠 Implication:
Maize is an outlier — it’s so altered that it can’t survive as-is in the wild. But gene flow with teosinte can blur the archaeological record.
🌾 4. Rice (Oryza sativa)
🧬 Domesticated Traits:
-
Shorter seed dormancy
-
Non-shattering grains
-
Compact panicles (grain heads)
-
Reduced awns
🔄 Feralization:
-
Rice rapidly feralizes — a major modern problem known as weedy rice or red rice.
-
This happens through:
-
Escape from fields
-
Hybridization with wild rice (O. rufipogon)
-
-
Traits like seed shattering, dormancy, and red pericarps reappear in <10 generations.
📌 Weedy rice is genetically part-domesticated but behaves wild — showing how quickly selection pressure can undo human cultivation traits.
🧠 Implication:
Rice demonstrates how fast domesticated traits can be lost in just decades. This has serious implications for interpreting early rice domestication in East and Southeast Asia.
🧾 Overall Takeaways
| Plant | Speed of Feralization | Key Points |
|---|---|---|
| Wheat | Slow–moderate (centuries) | Stable once fully domesticated; partial reversions |
| Barley | Fast–moderate (decades–centuries) | Hybridizes easily; common weedy forms |
| Maize | Rare, via hybridization only | Cannot survive without human aid, but gene flow with teosinte confuses the picture |
| Rice | Fast (within decades) | Weedy forms arise quickly; feral rice is a major modern issue |
🌱 Final Thought
These examples show that:
-
Domestication is reversible, especially in early stages.
-
Many early agricultural episodes could disappear from the archaeological record within centuries, due to feralization.
-
Therefore, true beginnings of agriculture may predate the first archaeobotanical evidence by millennia.
Would you like a diagram or timeline showing how these crops evolved across time and geography?
_(cropped).jpg/440px-P20210224CW-0490_(51013314422)_(cropped).jpg)