Tuesday, May 13, 2025

They came from hyper-space

 


The Skeptic AI has the floor...

Is there any scientific evidence for paralllel universes or other dimensions? For instance, in superstring theory, there are 16 dimensions coiled up in small superstring. Could these dimensions be larger?

Great question — and a big one that sits at the frontier of theoretical physics.

Scientific Evidence for Parallel Universes or Extra Dimensions:

As of today, there is no direct experimental or observational evidence for the existence of parallel universes or extra spatial dimensions. However, certain theoretical frameworks in modern physics predict or allow for these possibilities. Let’s break this down:


1. Extra Dimensions in String Theory (and M-Theory)

  • String Theory proposes that the fundamental particles are not point-like but rather tiny vibrating strings.

  • For the mathematics of string theory to be consistent, it requires extra spatial dimensions beyond the familiar three. Typically:

    • Superstring theory requires 10 dimensions (9 spatial + 1 time).

    • M-theory, a more unified version, requires 11 dimensions.

Compactification:

  • These extra dimensions are thought to be "compactified" — curled up so tightly (e.g., on the order of the Planck length: ~10⁻³⁵ meters) that we don’t experience or detect them in everyday life.

  • This compactification is often visualized using Calabi–Yau manifolds — complex geometric shapes that “hide” the extra dimensions.

Could They Be Larger?

  • Yes, in principle. Some extensions (like the Randall–Sundrum models) propose that one or more extra dimensions might be larger than previously assumed — even macroscopic — but their geometry could “warp” gravity, making them hard to detect.

  • These "large extra dimension" models have led to experimental proposals, such as trying to detect deviations from Newtonian gravity at very short distances, but no deviation has yet been found.


2. Parallel Universes (Multiverse Hypotheses)

There are several types of multiverse theories, and string theory intersects with some:

a) Quantum Multiverse (Many-Worlds Interpretation)

  • In quantum mechanics, the Many-Worlds Interpretation (MWI) posits that every quantum event branches the universe into multiple outcomes — a kind of parallel universe.

  • It’s logically consistent and widely discussed, but there’s no way to test it empirically (yet), so it's speculative.

b) Inflationary Multiverse

  • Cosmic inflation theory suggests our universe may be one bubble in a vast “multiverse” — each bubble having different physical constants or laws.

  • This idea is supported by models of inflation, but again, we cannot observe beyond our cosmic horizon, so it's not testable with current technology.

c) String Landscape

  • String theory allows for a vast number (10¹⁰⁰ to 10⁵⁰⁰) of possible vacuum states, each corresponding to different physical laws.

  • Some physicists suggest each vacuum could correspond to a different universe in a “landscape multiverse”.


What About Scientific Evidence?

Currently, the evidence for any of these ideas is theoretical only:

  • No experiment has confirmed the existence of extra dimensions, parallel universes, or alternate realities.

  • The Large Hadron Collider (LHC) has searched for signs like missing energy or mini black holes that could indicate extra dimensions — but so far, nothing has been detected.


To Sum Up:

  • Yes, modern physics predicts extra dimensions and even parallel universes, particularly in string theory and cosmology.

  • No, we haven’t found direct scientific evidence yet.

  • These ideas are theoretically consistent, sometimes even elegant, but they remain speculative without experimental confirmation.

Would you like to know more about the experimental efforts to detect extra dimensions, or about philosophical implications of the multiverse?

What about the idea that UFOs and aliens can come from parallel universes or other dimensions? Would this be possible even in principle?

The idea that UFOs (Unidentified Flying Objects) or aliens might originate from parallel universes or other dimensions is a fascinating and often-cited possibility in both fringe speculation and some theoretical circles. Let’s evaluate this idea scientifically and philosophically, distinguishing what’s possible in principle from what is supported by evidence.


Is It Possible in Principle?

From a theoretical physics standpoint:
Yes — it's possible in principle, but only under very speculative assumptions.

1. Extra-Dimensional Beings or Travel:

  • String theory and M-theory posit extra spatial dimensions.

  • If these dimensions are real and accessible (beyond being compactified at Planck-scale), a sufficiently advanced civilization might, in principle, have the technology to enter or traverse them, possibly "sidestepping" normal 3D space.

2. Parallel Universes as Origin Points:

  • In many-worlds quantum theory or cosmic multiverse models, other universes could exist with different physics.

  • If a parallel universe shares a "brane" (in brane-world models) or is “close” in a higher-dimensional space, it's conceivable, though highly speculative, that energy or matter could pass between them.

3. Hypothetical Technologies:

Some physicists have speculated (in thought experiments) about:

  • Wormholes stabilized by exotic matter, which could connect distant points or even universes.

  • Warp drives (like Alcubierre drive), which rely on hypothetical physics to “bend” space-time.

In these speculative frameworks, a non-human intelligence could, in principle, find means to cross dimensions — but these ideas far exceed our technological understanding, and we have no observational support for such mechanisms.


What About Empirical Evidence?

There is no scientific evidence that:

  • UFOs are alien spacecraft.

  • UFOs originate from parallel universes or extra dimensions.

  • Aliens or other intelligences have visited Earth.

Despite some intriguing military and civilian sightings, as well as declassified videos showing unknown aerial phenomena:

  • These remain unexplained, not evidence of interdimensional travel.

  • The U.S. Department of Defense has acknowledged the reality of UAPs (Unidentified Aerial Phenomena) but offers no conclusion about their origin or nature.

Even if some UFOs exhibit flight characteristics beyond current human capabilities, this does not automatically imply exotic origin (alien or interdimensional); it could reflect limitations in instrumentation, data, or unknown natural phenomena.


🧠 Philosophical and Scientific Challenges:

1. Interdimensional Communication or Interaction:

  • If beings from another dimension exist, it’s unclear how they could interact with us physically.

  • Physics as we know it imposes constraints on what can move between dimensions (conservation laws, locality, etc.).

2. Ontological Gap:

  • There's a huge difference between something being logically possible and physically plausible or evidenced.

  • The burden of proof remains with those claiming such entities are real and visit us.


🧭 Summary:

QuestionScientific Status
Could other dimensions or parallel universes exist?Theoretically possible in modern physics (string theory, cosmology)
Could intelligent beings emerge there?Possible in principle, though purely speculative
Could they visit us via those dimensions?Extremely speculative, would require physics we don’t understand
Is there evidence UFOs are from such realms?No direct or indirect evidence to support this idea

The idea is a legitimate thought experiment, but it currently belongs more to science fiction or philosophical speculation than science.

Would you like to explore how these ideas appear in serious scientific literature versus popular culture? 

1 comment:

  1. This is an excellent dialogue! The vibrating string theory is a fascinating topic. Reminds me of good ol' Gurdjieff's enneagram. 1 divided by 7 = 142857. What's hidden? 3--6-9 aka the Trinity, the hidden face of Allah etc.

    ReplyDelete