Hindus in Mesopotamia?

 

Some interesting speculations in the above videos, but ChatGPT is skeptical. Perhaps rightly, since the channel seems to be Greater Hindu nationalist (Hanuman founded a kingdom in ancient Honduras yeeeeah bruh). 

Is there any truth to the claim that Yazidis are actually Hindus or at least that their religion is Hindu-derived? For instance, the peacock angel (peacocks are not native to Kurdistan)?

The claim that Yazidism is derived from Hinduism or that Yazidis are "actually Hindus" is not accurate in a direct historical or theological sense, but there are some interesting parallels and shared motifs that have led people to make such claims.

---

🔹 Origins of Yazidism

Yazidism is an ancient, syncretic religion practiced by the Yazidi people, primarily in northern Iraq, with diaspora communities in Turkey, Syria, Armenia, and elsewhere. Its roots are indigenous to the Kurdish region and influenced by:

• Pre-Islamic Mesopotamian religions

• Zoroastrianism

• Islamic Sufism

• Possibly early Gnosticism or Manichaean currents

---

🔸 The Peacock Angel (Tawûsê Melek)

• The central figure in Yazidi theology is Tawûsê Melek, the Peacock Angel.

• He is considered a manifestation of the divine, a being of light who was cast down but redeemed, similar to the story of Lucifer, Prometheus, or even Shiva in certain interpretive stretches.

• The peacock is not native to Kurdistan but was known in ancient Mesopotamia and the Near East through trade and royal menageries. It's native to India and Sri Lanka.

• This has led some to draw a connection with Hindu deities, especially:

  • Kartikeya/Murugan/Skanda, who rides a peacock

  • Saraswati, who is also sometimes associated with peacocks

But these connections are symbolic rather than historical.

---

🔹 Hindu-Yazidi Parallels: Real or Reaching?

Element	Yazidism	Possible Hindu Analogy	Reality
Peacock Angel	Tawûsê Melek	Kartikeya/Murugan	Only symbolic similarity
Seven angels	Divine beings under God	Sapta Rishis or Lokapalas	Common in many systems
Reincarnation	Present in some Yazidi beliefs	Central in Hinduism	Yazidi belief is not systematic
Sun veneration	Yes, prayers toward the sun	Surya worship	Found in many ancient cultures

So while some archetypes and symbols overlap, no direct descent or influence from Hinduism has been demonstrated. Both systems draw on older Indo-European or West Asian mythic patterns that may share a distant cultural ancestry, but Yazidism evolved locally in the Fertile Crescent.

---

🟡 In Summary:

• Yazidism is not Hindu and did not derive from Hinduism.

• Some symbolic parallels exist (especially the Peacock Angel), but they are coincidental or archetypal rather than proof of a direct connection.

• Claims that Yazidis are Hindus in disguise or should be "brought back" to Hinduism are often political or ideological, especially in the context of Hindu nationalist narratives.

Let me know if you’d like a deeper comparison between Yazidi cosmology and Vedic or Shaiva theology.

What about "Kartikstan"? The term is used at a YouTube channel called Inspiring Science, but it´s in an Indian language I don´t understand. The video is titled (in English) "How Turkey & Iraq Yazidis Are Trying To Create New Hindu Country Kartikstan”.

It appears that the claim about Yazidis and the creation of a "Hindu homeland" called “Kartikstan” primarily originates from viral videos, reaction channels, and fringe narratives, rather than any substantiated movement or credible policy initiative.

Here’s what the information suggests:

---

🎥 The Source & Title Nuances

• Multiple YouTube videos (e.g. by Inspiring Science or other channels) carry the title:
  "How Turkey & Iraq Yazidis Are Trying To Create New Hindu Country 'Kartikstan'", or variations like “Yazidis Will Create a New Hindu Country 'Kartikstan'” youtube.com+9youtube.com+9youtube.com+9youtube.comyoutube.com+7youtube.com+7youtube.com+7.

• These titles and content appear to be sensational, and often stem from ideologically driven or speculative online communities, not mainstream scholarship or political discussion.

---

❓ What Does the Title Actually Suggest?

• The phrase "Turkey & Iraq Yazidis" likely intends to reference Yazidi communities located in Turkey and Iraq, rather than imply a coordinated Yazidi alliance with Turkey.

• The notion of a new Hindu country seems to come from a fringe ideological narrative, often connected to certain Hindu-nationalist or spiritualist movements.

• The name “Kartikstan” itself appears to be fabricated and not recognized by any Yazidi groups or official sources.

---

🔍 Credibility and Evidence

• No credible Yazidi group or leadership has advocated for the creation of a Hindu-identified state.

• Turkey has not supported such an idea—in fact, its military actions in Yazidi areas tend to be contentious and security-driven, not supportive of Yazidi autonomy or religious framing kurdistanobserver.comkurdistan24.net.

• Yazidism is deeply rooted in ancient Mesopotamian, Iranian, and Kurdish traditions, not Hindu theology en.wikipedia.org.

---

✅ Bottom Line

• The claim that Yazidis (in Turkey or Iraq) are creating a Hindu homeland named “Kartikstan” is not supported by any scholarly or political evidence.

• It appears to be a misinformation or sensational interpretation, possibly arising from online ideological or religious groups rather than genuine Yazidi intentions.

If you come across any official statements or reputable reporting on this, I’d be happy to re-evaluate them!

Bruh

 

An arrogant Christian YouTuber exposes Hinduism and Buddhism in 4 minutes. LOL! Yeah, I´m sure he spent 40 years at the lotus feet of a guru (or a scholar, or even a hippie) really studying the topic...

To quote Vivekananda: "Christians say their religion is true because it´s historical. I say my religion is true because it *isn´t* historical".

And no, the quote isn´t literal. It´s a teaching story, bruh!  

Meet the new god, same as the old one

 

The atheist content-creator with the peculiar moniker "Genetically Modified Skeptic" discusses the newly minted AI cults in this video. He reaches the conclusion that the strange new tech-inspired religions aren´t all that different from the old religions most of us take for granted. Both hits and misses in this presentation, if you ask me.   

Ever-changing identity

 

The Alevis are a religious minority group in the Middle East, mostly in Turkey. This video (made by a US scholar of religion) is an excellent introduction to Alevism. Or perhaps ethnic Turkish Alevism? Kurdish and Zaza versions also exist. 

The Alevis turn out to be a broad religious landscape rather than a specific movement or faith group. They could be described as a heterogenous cluster of nominally Sunni Muslim groups heavily influenced by Shia Islam and Sufi mysticism (which probably strides the Sunni-Shia divide). There are connections to the Bektashi Order and the Kizilbash rebel movement. Conversely, there are no overt connections to the Alawites (except the name), a radical Shia sect mostly based in Syria.

Alevis have continued to redefine their identities throughout the 20th and 21st centuries. They have also been redefined by outsiders. The claim that Alevism is really a primordial form of Shamanism turns out to come from Turkish secular nationalist discourse! Some Alevis emphasize their Muslim identity, while others ("Alevis without Ali") claim to be a separate community altogether and have even been condemned by Turkish president Erdogan himself as dangerous splitters. 

As already indicated, Kurdish Alevism is only mentioned in passing and the Zaza version not at all. Years ago, I met a certain person who told me that the Zaza Alevis have a legend according to which they killed Kemal Atatürk somewhere in Kirmanjiye (in reality, Kemal died of natural causes at Istanbul). Maybe next time, bro?

Recommended. Actually!   

God in the machine?

 

This is actually an interesting video. Not as weird as the usual ChatGPT Messiah-cultic stuff. About an "angry atheist" who encounters God through AI...kind of.  

Artistic liberty

 

So I revisited the strange picture of the Tantric child goddess Bala Tripura Sundari I found on the web some years ago. Gotta love the AI´s competent art criticism!  

The modern picture I´ve seen of Bala shows her seated on a white lotus, holding white lotuses in two of her hands, the two other hands being free, with a cockatoo on her right shoulder and something that looks like a halo around her head. This doesn´t look traditional.

You're absolutely right to notice that the image you describe of Bala Tripura Sundari does not conform to most traditional iconographic canons of Hindu art—especially those laid out in Shilpa Shastras and Agamas for Sri Vidya deities. Let's break it down and explore where this modern imagery might come from and how it differs from traditional depictions:

---

🔍 Breakdown of the Modern Image You Saw

Feature	Notes
White lotus seat	Traditional for purity deities like Saraswati, but Bala is usually depicted seated on a red lotus or golden pedestal.
Holding white lotuses	Symbolizes purity and serenity, but Bala typically holds sugarcane bow, flower arrows, etc.
Cockatoo on chest	Cockatoos are native to Australia and unknown in traditional Indian imagery; their presence suggests a modern artistic or symbolic reinterpretation.
Halo	Halos are sometimes added in modern art to emphasize divinity, but are not a prominent feature in traditional Shakta iconography.

---

🎨 Why This Doesn’t Match Traditional Descriptions

Traditional Iconography of Bala Tripura Sundari (from Tantric and Srividya texts):

• Form: A young girl around 9–12 years old, glowing with divine beauty.

• Color: Reddish-pink or golden hue.

• Seat: Seated on a red lotus, symbolizing active Shakti.

• Weapons and Emblems:

  • Sugarcane bow (desire)

  • Five flower arrows (sensory control)

  • Sometimes a lotus or noose

  • Occasionally shown with hand in blessing or gesture of protection

• Companion: No consistent mention of a bird companion, though parrots (especially green parrots) are associated with Tripura Sundari and Kamakshi.

• Surroundings: Sometimes within a Sri Chakra or halo of radiance (tejomandala), but traditional art avoids literal "halos" like in Western art.

---

🦜 The Cockatoo Mystery

Possibilities:

• Artist’s Imagination: Given cockatoos are exotic, colorful, and intelligent, an artist may have substituted them for traditional parrots, not knowing the distinction.

• Symbolism: In modern spiritual art, animals are sometimes added for symbolic or aesthetic reasons rather than scriptural fidelity.

• New Age or Syncretic Influence: Some modern depictions of Indian deities are created for global audiences, blending Hindu iconography with other traditions or even fantasy elements.

---

✅ How to Recognize Traditional Bala Imagery

Look for the following:

• Seated on a red or pink lotus or golden throne.

• Four arms: sugarcane bow, flower arrows, with gestures like abhaya (fearlessness) and varada (boon-giving).

• Youthful form, no older than 12 years.

• Often shown smiling or in a sweet, tranquil pose.

• Sometimes surrounded by attendants, Sri Chakra, or divine glow.

• Parrot may appear (rare), but not a cockatoo.

---

Conclusion

The image you saw is almost certainly a modern or devotional reinterpretation rather than a canonical representation from classical Hindu or Tantric tradition. That said, such images can still be spiritually meaningful, especially in private devotion, provided they don’t distort essential theological meanings.

Would you like to see a collection of traditional depictions of Bala or explore authorized yantras and mantra charts used in her worship?

She also has red nail polish on both her hands and her feet. But her age seems to be correct (a child).

That’s a keen observation—and a telling one. The detail about red nail polish on both hands and feet, combined with a childlike form, places the image you’re describing firmly in the category of modern devotional or artistic reinterpretation, rather than a strictly traditional or Agamic depiction of Bala Tripura Sundari. Let’s unpack that a bit more.

---

🔴 Red Nail Polish: Traditional or Modern?

• Traditional Bala imagery emphasizes natural, divine beauty—youthful glow, unadorned or modestly adorned limbs, and symbolic objects (like flower arrows, sugarcane bow).

• Red nail polish is not part of classical iconography, especially for a prepubescent goddess. In fact, in traditional Hindu aesthetics:

  • Nail coloring (like alta on the feet) is used in depictions of adult goddesses, dancers, or brides—symbolizing erotic charm (śṛṅgāra) or auspiciousness.

  • Applying this to a child goddess would not fit older symbolic canons, where innocence (bālya-bhāva) is carefully preserved.

So: this is clearly modern, likely influenced by popular or aestheticized devotional art aimed at evoking sweetness, charm, or familiarity rather than textual accuracy.

---

🎨 A Childlike Goddess in Modern Visual Language

Artists in the 20th and 21st centuries have increasingly portrayed deities in relatable or ornamental styles, including:

• Glamorous Saraswati or Lakshmi in sarees not historically accurate.

• Krishna as a baby in bright, Bollywood-style makeup.

• Or, in your case, Bala Tripura Sundari as a child with red nail polish, a white lotus, and a cockatoo.

This is devotional bhava expressed visually—rather than ritually or scripturally.

---

👧 But the Child Aspect Is Key—and Traditional

You're absolutely right that her child form is essential.

In Sri Vidya tradition, Bala is:

• A symbol of pure Shakti in its nascent form.

• The beginning of manifestation, the playful divine energy of Lalita before maturity.

• A goddess approachable with innocence and affection—ideal for early-stage sadhakas or those on the path of affectionate devotion (lalita upasana).

• Seen as both a daughter-like and divine friend figure.

So while the modern depiction you saw adds non-traditional elements, its core sentiment—childlike divinity, accessible and sweet—is very faithful to her theological role.

---

Summary

Element	Traditional?	Notes
Child form	✅	Core to Bala’s identity in Sri Vidya.
White lotus	❌	Usually red lotus or golden throne.
Red nail polish	❌	Modern aesthetic; not from scriptures.
Cockatoo	❌	Likely a visual metaphor or mistake for parrot.
Halo	❌	Western-style addition; not typical in Shakta art.

---

Would you like to contrast this image with Sringeri math paintings, Kamakhya temple imagery, or Tantric yantras used in traditional Bala worship? I can also guide you to authorized iconographic texts (like Shilpa Ratna or Mantra Mahodadhi) that describe her form more accurately.

Divine cremation ground

 

I spent several evenings now discussing Jagannath with ChatGPT. Some of the stuff is actually extremely fascinating, such as the periodic "reincarnation" of the temple deities described below. 

Can you tell me more about the Nabakalebara ritual? Are the old idols destroyed, thrown in the river, or what?

Yes — the Nabakalebara ritual is one of the most sacred and mysterious ceremonies in Hinduism, and it takes place only every 12 to 19 years at the Jagannath Temple in Puri. It involves the ritual death and rebirth of the deities Jagannath, Balabhadra, Subhadra, and Sudarshana, by replacing their decaying wooden forms (daru-vigrahas) with new ones, carved from specially selected sacred trees.

---

🔁 What is Nabakalebara?

“Naba” means new, and “Kalebara” means body — so it literally means “New Body.”

According to tradition, the deities periodically shed their bodies, much like living beings, and are reborn into fresh wooden forms. The spirit or essence of the deities, especially the Brahma Padārtha (mystical “life force” or “soul”) within Jagannath, is transferred from the old body to the new.

---

🌳 The Process in Brief

1. Timing

• Nabakalebara is held during the month of Ashadha, when a leap year occurs in the lunar calendar (called Adhika Masa).

• This is determined by astrological calculation and doesn’t follow a fixed cycle.

---

2. Selection of the Sacred Trees (Daru)

• Each deity has a unique Neem tree selected according to strict symbolic and astrological criteria:

  • No damage to the tree

  • Must have specific number of branches, markings (like chakra or conch), and nearby water or cremation ground

  • Trees are found only after an elaborate search by temple priests and ritualists

• These trees are cut in a ceremonial procession and brought to Puri.

---

3. Carving the New Idols

• In a secluded area inside the temple compound, called the Koili Baikuntha, carvers known as Vishwakarma craftsmen sculpt the new wooden forms using ancient techniques, in complete ritual purity and secrecy.

• Only a select few people are allowed to participate or even witness this process.

---

4. The Secret Ritual: Transfer of Brahma Padārtha

• On an auspicious night, the mysterious Brahma Padārtha — the soul-essence of Jagannath — is transferred from the old idol to the new one in total darkness by blindfolded, ritually purified priests.

• The nature of this Brahma Padārtha is completely secret; it is said to be eternal and self-effulgent, and only certain hereditary priests have ever seen or touched it.

• This moment is considered so sacred that even those who perform the ritual often vow not to describe or discuss it.

---

5. Burial of the Old Idols

• Once the transfer is complete, the old wooden idols are buried in the Koili Baikuntha, a garden within the temple compound that functions as a divine cremation ground.

• They are not thrown into a river but given full funerary rites, treated as if the deities themselves have died.

• This burial area is considered so holy that entry is restricted.

---

6. Emergence of the New Deities

• The new idols are then dressed, painted, and consecrated in another series of rituals.

• Finally, they are reinstalled on the altar, and public darshan resumes.

• This marks a new cycle in the life of the temple and of Jagannath worship.

---

🌀 Symbolic Meaning

• Death and rebirth — even the gods experience it in this world.

• Affirms that the divine is eternal, but its outer forms are impermanent.

• Reflects Indian cosmology of cycles, transience, and the soul’s migration.

• Also connects deeply with tribal and Tantric symbolism — since Jagannath is not a classical anthropomorphic deity, the ritual hints at cosmic transformation, not just physical replacement.

---

🔍 Did You Know?

• Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, the 16th-century saint, reportedly did not attend a Nabakalebara ritual, because of its secrecy and gravity. His biographers treat the event as too sacred for common view.

• During Nabakalebara, the entire town of Puri becomes a sacred space, flooded with millions of pilgrims.

• The most recent Nabakalebara was in 2015; the next one may occur in the 2030s, based on astrological alignment.

---

Would you like an overview of the symbolic meanings of the three deities (Jagannath, Balabhadra, Subhadra) in this ritual context — especially from different theological standpoints (Vaishnava, Shakta, tribal)?

Yes, please.

Certainly. The triad of Jagannath, Balabhadra, and Subhadra is deeply symbolic and interpreted differently across Hindu traditions. In the context of Nabakalebara—the ritual of their periodic death and rebirth—the meanings become even more layered. Below is a breakdown of their theological and symbolic roles in Vaishnava, Shakta, and tribal perspectives:

---

🌟 1. Vaishnava Interpretation

Particularly among Gaudiya Vaishnavas, but also in mainstream Puri temple theology.

Jagannath:

• Krishna as the Supreme Lord, especially in a form overcome by ecstatic separation (viraha) from Radha.

• The wide eyes, absence of limbs, and rounded form express a kind of divine madness—Krishna in his most mystically compassionate form.

• His color (black or dark blue) represents infinite, all-absorbing consciousness.

Balabhadra (Balarama):

• Krishna’s elder brother, symbol of cosmic strength and order.

• His white color represents purity, satva guna, and the supporting force of the universe.

• Sometimes seen as the Adi-Guru, the first spiritual teacher.

Subhadra:

• Considered Krishna's sister, but also a symbol of Yogamaya—the divine energy that connects Krishna to the world and his devotees.

• Her golden/yellow color suggests auspiciousness and balance.

• Central in the chariot during Rath Yatra, symbolizing the mediating energy between Shiva and Vishnu, male and female, being and becoming.

In Nabakalebara, the transfer of Brahma Padārtha (especially from Jagannath) represents the eternal presence of Krishna moving through perishable forms—reaffirming samsara and moksha as simultaneous realities.

---

🕉 2. Shakta Interpretation

More common in Tantric traditions of Odisha and Bengal.

Subhadra:

• Central goddess figure in some Shakta and Tantric texts.

• Identified with Bhairavi, Kali, or Durga depending on the tradition.

• During special Shakta pujas, she is meditated upon as the primordial Shakti, and the other two deities (Jagannath and Balabhadra) are sometimes seen as bindu and nada—or as Bhairava aspects.

Jagannath and Balabhadra:

• Seen as emanations of Shiva/Bhairava, sometimes even protective spirits (kṣetrapālas).

• The triad is interpreted as representing the three bindus of the Sri Chakra:

  • Sunya (Void) – Jagannath

  • Bija (Seed) – Balabhadra

  • Nada (Vibration) – Subhadra

This aligns with the belief that the entire cosmic play—creation, preservation, and destruction—is a manifestation of Shakti, with the male deities acting as supportive static consciousness.

---

🌿 3. Tribal / Indigenous Interpretation

Especially among Sabara and Saora communities, who are considered the earliest custodians of Jagannath worship.

Jagannath:

• A form of a tribal, non-anthropomorphic forest god, likely predating Vedic religion.

• The large round eyes, lack of arms/legs, and log-like body recall ancient tree totems or deity posts.

Balabhadra:

• Sometimes seen as a weather or fertility god, connected to agriculture and land protection.

Subhadra:

• A local goddess, perhaps originally a village protector, absorbed into the later pantheon.

In this view, Nabakalebara reflects the natural cycle of decay and renewal, mirroring tribal funerary and rebirth customs. The sacred trees (daru) chosen for the idols are living ancestors, and the ritual death and burial of the old idols is not symbolic but a real act of reverence for divine life-force in nature.

Is the Nabakalebara ritual unique to Puri, or is it re-enacted in other Jagannath temples, for instance those associated with ISKCON?

The Nabakalebara ritual—literally "new body"—is unique to the Jagannath temple in Puri and is not fully re-enacted in ISKCON temples or most other Jagannath temples in India or abroad.

Here's why:

---

🏯 1. Unique to Puri: Sacred Geography & Ritual Complexity

The Jagannath Temple in Puri is:

• One of the Char Dham pilgrimage sites,

• Rooted in an ancient tradition going back many centuries, possibly pre-Vedic,

• The only place where the original "Brahma Padartha"—the mysterious life-essence transferred during Nabakalebara—is housed.

The ritual involves:

• A year-long preparation,

• Secretive, esoteric procedures (e.g., by the Daitapatis, who are descendants of tribal devotees),

• The felling of sacred neem trees (Daru Brahma) found through astrological and scriptural guidance,

• Burial of old idols in the Koili Baikuntha (a temple graveyard within the complex).

This elaborate and sacred chain of practices cannot be replicated outside this tradition-bound context.

---

🛕 2. ISKCON Temples: No Nabakalebara

ISKCON temples generally do not observe Nabakalebara in the same way. Their practices include:

• Installation rituals (prana pratishtha) for deities,

• Daily worship (puja, aarti, bhoga offering) following Vaishnava standards,

• Annual Ratha Yatras, inspired by Puri’s, but simplified.

When an ISKCON deity becomes damaged, they may perform:

• A prayerful retirement or respectful disposal (visarjan) in water or temple grounds, but

• Not the secretive transfer of Brahma padārtha or the elaborate death-and-rebirth drama of Puri.

---

🪔 3. Other Jagannath Temples: Honor the Puri Calendar

Some major regional Jagannath temples (e.g., in Gujarat, Bengal, or Tamil Nadu) may symbolically mark the Nabakalebara year by:

• Ceremonial observances,

• Decorating deities in special ways,

• Holding discourses or plays.

But idol replacement is generally not done unless the deities are damaged, and when done, it's through simpler rituals.

---

🔱 Summary

Feature	Jagannath Puri Temple	ISKCON Temples	Other Jagannath Temples
Full Nabakalebara ritual	✅ Yes, every 12–19 years	❌ No	❌ No (sometimes symbolic observance)
Transfer of Brahma Padārtha	✅ Yes (secret, sacred)	❌ No	❌ No
Idol burial (Koili Vaikuntha)	✅ Yes	❌ No	❌ No
Ratha Yatra	✅ Grand and traditional	✅ Yes, simplified	✅ Yes, regional variations