“Fakta eller fantasier. Föreställningar i vetenskapens
gränstrakter” is a Swedish book edited by Jesper Jerkert. It´s a sequel to ”Vetenskap eller
villfarelse”, which I haven´t read. Both books are written from a skeptical
perspective and reprints material from “Folkvett”, the magazine of the Swedish
skeptics´ organization VoF. Think “Skeptical Inquirer” and CSICOP and you get
at least some of the picture. Since the contributions are written by a diverse
bunch of authors and are often quite short, the quality of the material is
equally varied. Most of it is tolerable, regardless of whether you are a
skeptic or not. For obvious reasons, I found the Atlantis debunking
unconvincing, but YMMV. The book was published in 2007 and shows Olof Rudbeck
on its front flap! Yes, that would be the 17th century loco who
claimed that Sweden was, ahem, Atlantis…
One
contribution stands out, and I can´t help thinking that the editor might have
been trolling his readers. It´s the Dalkvist-Westerlund article on
parapsychology, which actually defends the idea that parapsychology is a
legitimate science, and criticizes its skeptical critics in some detail! I will
certainly use this piece, fully cross-referenced, in any future confrontation
with the Angry Atheist brigade (although I might just as well be sending it
telepathically to James Randi). Another intriguing article attacks Sigmund
Freud, painting him as a more or less conscious fraud. I noted that the article
attacks both his early “seduction theory” and his later idea that all memories
of sex abuse in early childhood are purely imaginary – both claims, the author
of the article claims, are Freud´s own speculations, since the psychoanalyst´s own case files back up neither. The author sees Freud as a seeker and intellectual
explorer who made the mistake of insisting that his wild ideas were
scientifically proven. (Velikovsky comes to mind here.)
Yet
another interesting piece deals with Environmental Somatization Syndrome (ESS),
including oral galvanism, Sick Building Syndrome (SBS), and oversensitivity to
electromagnetic fields. The author, a medical doctor, believes that these
syndromes are all in the mind, and tend to go away if the authorities simply
refuse to listen (and refuse to pay). The fact that each generation, or every
country, has its very own “ESS”, often connected to new forms of technology,
while the symptoms are identical, is to the author a good indicator that we are
dealing with problems that are at bottom psychological. Also, ESS-type symptoms *disappear* if a real toxin is present, to be replaced by the standard symptoms associated with that particular agent.
Lysenko,
alternative medicine, humanistic psychology, the new Swedish Bible translation,
dowsing, the Intelligent Design movement, the history of conspiracy theory, and
the differences between CSICOP and VoF are other topics covered in “Fakta eller
fantasier”.
Perhaps
not the best book around on the topics under debate, but quite well-crafted for
lighter weekend reading. If skepticism is your cup of tea (or homeopathic sugar
water), you probably won´t regret reading it.
Olof Rudbeck was obviously off his meds, everyone knows that Atlantis was in North America, sheesh!
ReplyDeleteIs angry atheism an ESS caused by too much exposure to American trash TV?
ReplyDelete