Showing posts with label Anglicanism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Anglicanism. Show all posts

Thursday, November 5, 2026

Liar, lunatic or Appolinarian?

 


A clever argument against C S Lewis´ Trilemma, arguing that it´s implicitly Apollinarian. And Appolinarianism is, ahem, an ancient heresy...

Check mate. 

Thursday, June 18, 2026

Scarabs and robins

 

Credit: Francis C Franklin

This doesn´t mean anything, but it´s a funny (and somewhat weird) co-incidence. Yesterday, I was strolling in the local parkland-or-very-managed-woodland, reflecting on the Upanishads, Enneads and what have you. At one point, I wondered if there is a compassionate divine savior somewhere in the "pantheist" cosmos. Krishna, perhaps? 

*Immidiately after that* a European robin appeared and started flying/"dancing" around me. Eh? I usually don´t see robins in that part of the park. Or ever, really. When I asked ChatGPT about robins and folklore, it turned out that this particular bird is associated with...Christ?! The robin wanted to ease Christ´s suffering on the cross and therefore removed one of the thorns from the crown of thorns on his head. That is, both the bird and Jesus are "compassionate saviors". This lore seems to be English.

A sign from God that I should convert to Anglicanism? But then it struck me that some Hindus consider both Jesus and Krishna to be avatars of Vishnu. Indeed, the Hare Krishna leader Prabhupada even claimed that Christ and Krishna were the same person?!

Hmmm...

A co-incidence, of course. 

Friday, February 27, 2026

Tash is greater

 


Jay Dyer (!) discusses C S Lewis´ "Chronicles of Narnia", specifically "The Horse and His Boy", seeing it as a veiled criticism of Islam. 

Monday, February 23, 2026

Election interference

 


The Church of England actually voted to terminate same-sex blessings?! An unexpected setback for the liberal Anglicans, obviously. 

Redeemed Zoomer (RZ) believes that the Woke will stage a comeback soon and push for same-sex marriage, and therefore calls on all conservative members of the Church to participate in the upcoming elections to the General Synod, its supreme decision-making body. RZ believes that of all liberal Churches, the Church of England is the one most likely to revert back to conservatism. Most practicing members are conservative. The conservatives are also relatively well organized.  

Apparently, the "GAFCON" split from the global Anglican communion last year was fake news. Most conservative Anglican Churches in the Global South have no plans to break communion with Canterbury. At least that´s what RZ believes. So the factional conflicts within both the CofE and its international network will continue for another decade or so...

I admit that I have no particular horse in this race, and will probably watch it mostly from the sidelines. 

Sunday, February 15, 2026

The pope is laughing

 


Not sure if this really means that much, but it´s fun listening to. Especially if you´re a nerd. It´s also a good summary of the bewildering diversity of Christian Churches and denominations. In practice, of course, even Churches that are in some sense "close" might hate each other - witness the rather rocky historical relations between Catholics and Orthodox. To mention just one example...

Protestants procreate through meiosis

 


Our man Joshua discusses some new denominations (or Churches...or God-knows-what) in the United States. 

The most "normal" is a Mennonite denomination which voluntarily split into three, to avoid making its bureaucracy too unwieldy. The others are marked by scheming, serious abuse allegations, or utter theological confusion. Delusions of grandeur play a part in some kind of new "Catholic" Church yada yada. 

I´m not a (Roman) Catholic, but I have to say that the picture of contemporary Protestantism which emerges here isn´t entirely sympathetic! 

Saturday, January 31, 2026

The Great Replacement, er, Realignment

 


What´s the future of Christianity in general and its various branches? Redeemed Zoomer speculates about what will happen in the next 100 years. I assume this is about the United States? 

What will *actually* happen globally (on current demographic trends) is that Euro-Christianity will be replaced by South Asian / Central Asian Islam or West African voodoo.

There, I said it. 

Sunday, January 25, 2026

Two and a half sacraments?

 


The Christian sacrament situation was even more complex than I expected. I had some kind of vague notion that while Catholics and Orthodox had exactly the same seven sacraments, Protestants only had two (or perhaps three). Except for the Salvation Army, which have none. 

But naaah. It´s much more complicated. Perhaps I shouldn´t be surprised. 

Thursday, October 30, 2025

No inkling



"There was a time when every tree, every brook, every hill was thought to be alive. The world is a haunted forest. Modern man has tried to exorcize it, but the ghosts still whisper." - Attributed to C S Lewis, but ChatGPT couldn´t find any credible source for the quote, so it´s probably apocryphal. But chilling nevertheless! Fairies?

Thursday, October 23, 2025

Where is king Charles?

 


I actually wondered about this myself. Sure, the British monarch has no effective power anymore, but since the Brits are high on formalities, I wondered if the split in the Anglican Communion could still impact him in some embarrassing way. But it seems the monarch is just a rubber stamp these days for decisions taken by the Church of England itself. So nah, Charles neither can nor will do anything. 

Note also that the king is only the Supreme Governor of the specifically English Church, not the Anglican Communion as a whole. According to Wiki, he´s not even the head of the Anglican Church in Scotland!

Everything is well in the world. Or no?    

Sunday, October 19, 2025

Schismatic



A sneak peek into the bewildering demimonde of conservative Anglicanism. Or perhaps its most "official" expressions. The recent split between the Church of England and GAFCON may lead to smaller splits from the English Church itself as conservative groups more loyal to GAFCON leave the Canterbury fold. Something they in effect have already done, since it seems these groups set up their own quasi-schismatic structures years ago. 

Note also the perhaps salient fact that the conservative faction is multi-ethnic and probably dominated by African Churches! Probably not a succesful brand of right-wing politics in the years ahead, but then, the entire concept of mostly non-English Anglicanism sounds strange in the first place... 

Friday, October 17, 2025

Anglicanism without England?

 


Not that I really care, but what could it even *mean* to have an Anglican Communion without the Church of England? Since when has "Anglicanism" been a thing at all, theologically speaking? What do you think the term even *means*? Cough, cough, Angles, cough, cough, England, cough, Church of England. It simply denotes "those Christians who are loyal to the English monarch". 

So unless the archbishop of Rwanda starts genuflecting for king Charles III as head of the Church and Commonwealth, he can´t claim to represent the Anglican Communion. Whoever Charles accepts communion from, that person is the legitimate archbishop of Canterbury. 

End of story. And end of the line? 

The future has arrived

 


2025 is the gift that never stops giving. Now, the Anglican Communion has finally split. 

Strictly speaking, the GAFCON organization has declared itself to be the true Anglican Communion. In other words: this self-proclaimed "Anglican Communion" has expelled the Church of England?! 

Amazing stuff. You can tell your grandchildren that you were there when it happened. From Joshua´s channel "Ready to Harvest". 

Tuesday, October 14, 2025

"Solo" scriptura

 


What´s the distinction between sola scriptura, prima scriptura and nuda scriptura (or "solo" scriptura)? In case this keeps you up at night, here´s a succinct exposition on this vexing topic. Thank you. 

Had I been a Christian, I would probably follow what brother Cooper calls "prima scriptura". He wouldn´t. But then, Cooper is an orthodox conservative Lutheran. And that´s that. 

Monday, October 13, 2025

Defcon Gafcon

 




Will the Anglican Communion finally split with the Church of England? And what took them so long? Our man Joshua has the latest news! 

The revenge of history?

Saturday, July 19, 2025

Christian ashram

 


Tonight´s robot essay. So I asked ChatGPT about Rupert Sheldrake´s teacher or guru in India, Father Bede Griffiths. Ahem, that´s a strange name for a Hindu guru?! Here is what I found out...

Who was Father Bede Griffiths who had an ashram in India and was the teacher of Rupert Sheldrake?

Father Bede Griffiths (1906–1993) was a British-born Benedictine monk, Christian mystic, and interfaith pioneer who became known for his work integrating Christianity and Hinduism. He spent much of his life in India, where he lived in an ashram and taught a form of Christian Vedānta—a contemplative path combining Christian monasticism with Indian spirituality.


🧔 Who Was He?

  • Birth name: Alan Richard Griffiths

  • Born: 1906, Walton-on-Thames, England

  • Died: 1993, Tamil Nadu, India

  • Religious background: Raised Anglican, converted to Roman Catholicism in 1931

  • Became a Benedictine monk at Prinknash Abbey in England

He was also a student of C.S. Lewis at Oxford and part of the literary Christian intellectual circle there.


🌏 His Journey to India

In 1955, Griffiths moved to India, feeling called to explore the mystical and contemplative dimensions of Hinduism. Over time, he increasingly wore ochre robes, adopted the sannyāsin lifestyle, and engaged deeply with Advaita Vedānta, especially as presented by figures like Śaṅkara and Sri Ramana Maharshi.


🕉️ The Shantivanam Ashram

  • He eventually settled at the Shantivanam Ashram in Tamil Nadu (founded by Fr. Jules Monchanin and Henri Le Saux a.k.a. Abhishiktananda).

  • There, he practiced and taught a Christianized version of Vedānta, encouraging a unitive experience of God beyond doctrinal boundaries.

  • The ashram emphasized:

    • Silent meditation

    • Chanting both Vedic and Christian scriptures

    • Interfaith dialogue

    • Simple monastic living

🗣️ Griffiths believed that Christ is the fulfillment of Vedānta, not in a missionary or colonial sense, but in a universal mystical sense.


🧠 Relationship with Rupert Sheldrake

  • Rupert Sheldrake, the biologist known for proposing morphic resonance, met Griffiths in India in the 1980s.

  • Sheldrake credits Bede Griffiths as a spiritual mentor and intellectual influence, particularly in helping him see the spiritual and philosophical limitations of materialism.

  • They shared an interest in consciousness, mysticism, and breaking down the Western separation between science and spirituality.


📘 Key Writings by Bede Griffiths

  • The Marriage of East and West

  • Return to the Center

  • A New Vision of Reality

  • The Cosmic Revelation

These works combine Christian theology, Vedāntic philosophy, and Jungian psychology, seeking a universal mystical core in the world's religions.


🕊️ His Legacy

  • He’s often cited alongside Thomas Merton and Abhishiktananda as a bridge between Eastern and Western contemplative traditions.

  • Advocated for interspirituality, a deeper communion among faiths at the mystical level.

  • Today, his ashram continues to host seekers of various traditions who explore nondual spirituality through a Christian lens.


Would you like a quote from Griffiths or one of his key teachings on integrating Christ and the Self (ātman)?

Who was Fr Jules Monchanin and Henri Le Saux?

Fr Jules Monchanin and Henri Le Saux (also known as Swami Abhishiktananda) were two pioneering Catholic monks and mystics who laid the foundations for interfaith dialogue and Christian–Hindu monastic integration in 20th-century India.

They were the co-founders of the Saccidananda Ashram (later known as Shantivanam) in Tamil Nadu, which became a major center for Christian–Vedantic contemplative life—later continued and expanded by Bede Griffiths.


🔹 Father Jules Monchanin (1895–1957)

📖 Background:

  • French Catholic priest and theologian

  • Deeply drawn to Indian spirituality and mysticism

  • Arrived in India in 1939

  • Embraced elements of Advaita Vedānta while remaining firmly Trinitarian

🧘 Role in Interfaith Dialogue:

  • Wrote under the Indian name "Swami Paramarubyananda" (Swami of the Supreme Spirit)

  • Sought to "Hinduize" Christian contemplation, not by syncretism, but by a deep encounter with the Indian tradition

  • Emphasized inner transformation, simplicity, and inculturation of Christianity into Indian soil

  • He wrote extensively on Christian mysticism and Indian metaphysics

“India is a land of seeking. The Christ we bring must speak to the inner realization India longs for.”


🔹 Henri Le Saux / Swami Abhishiktananda (1910–1973)

📖 Background:

  • French Benedictine monk

  • Came to India in 1948 to join Monchanin

  • Adopted the name Swami Abhishiktananda ("bliss of the Anointed One")

  • Lived as a Christian sannyāsi, practicing intense Advaitic meditation and Hindu-Christian mystical synthesis

🕉️ Spiritual Path:

  • Deeply influenced by Ramana Maharshi and the experience of the Self (Ātman)

  • Had powerful nondual mystical experiences, which he struggled to reconcile with traditional Christian dogma

  • His writings explore the tension and convergence between Christian mystical experience and Advaita Vedānta

📝 Key Works:

  • Saccidananda: A Christian Approach to Advaitic Experience

  • The Further Shore

  • The Secret of Arunachala

“The depth of the Self is the depth of God. It is there that Christ is born.”


🌿 Saccidananda Ashram (Shantivanam)

  • Founded in 1950 by Monchanin and Le Saux

  • "Saccidananda" = Being–Consciousness–Bliss, a Sanskrit expression for the divine in Advaita Vedānta—and reinterpreted by them as a Christian symbol for the Trinity

  • A center of Christian monasticism in Indian form:

    • Wore ochre robes

    • Practiced daily meditation, chanting, and Hindu-style rituals infused with Christian meaning

    • Aimed for a deep encounter between East and West

🕊️ The ashram was later led by Bede Griffiths, who carried their vision forward into a more public and global platform.


🪔 Legacy

  • Monchanin was the intellectual theologian, cautious and exacting

  • Le Saux was the mystic adventurer, willing to plunge deeply into Advaita and let it shake him to the core

  • Together, they represent a radical experiment in interreligious encounter, rooted not in comparison, but in lived contemplative experience

Their work helped inspire the Christian Ashram movement, and today they are remembered as spiritual pioneers of interfaith mysticism.


Would you like excerpts from their writings or a comparison of their views on Advaita and Christ?

What is the Christian Ashram movement?

The Christian Ashram Movement is a spiritual and monastic initiative that seeks to express Christian faith using the forms, language, and lifestyle of Indian spiritual traditions, especially Hinduism. It emerged in the 20th century as a response to the encounter between Christianity and Indian culture, particularly in the context of monasticism, contemplation, and interreligious dialogue.


🕉️ What Is an “Ashram”?

In Hindu tradition, an ashram is a spiritual hermitage or monastery—a place for:

  • Simple, disciplined living

  • Meditation and prayer

  • Study and spiritual guidance

  • Renunciation of worldly distractions

The Christian Ashram movement adopts this form while centering the Christian mystical path—particularly contemplative prayer, service, and Christ-centered devotion.


🌱 Origins and Influences

🧘 Founded in India in the early-mid 20th century by:

  1. Jules Monchanin (Swami Paramarubyananda)

  2. Henri Le Saux (Swami Abhishiktananda)

  3. Bede Griffiths
    → These three were the core initiators of the Christian Ashram movement.

They believed:

  • Christianity could be authentically expressed in Indian spiritual language

  • Christ could be experienced through deep Advaitic (nondual) meditation

  • Christian monasticism could take Indian forms (robes, names, rituals, diet, silence)


✝️ Key Characteristics of Christian Ashrams

FeatureDescription
Christ-centered lifeJesus is the center, but interpreted sometimes in mystical or universal terms
Indian lifestyleSannyāsa robes, vegetarianism, simplicity, celibacy
Meditation & prayerSilence, mantra (e.g., "Jesus," "Om Christu"), contemplative practices
Scriptural dialogueStudy of both Bible and Hindu texts (Upanishads, Gita)
InculturationIntegration of Indian philosophy, music, ritual forms
Interreligious opennessDeep respect for Hindu sages and spiritual paths

🏞️ Notable Christian Ashrams

1. Shantivanam Ashram (Tamil Nadu)

  • Most well-known Christian ashram

  • Founded by Monchanin and Le Saux in 1950

  • Later led by Bede Griffiths, who made it internationally known

2. Saccidananda Ashram

  • Original name of Shantivanam

  • "Sat–Cit–Ananda" (Being–Consciousness–Bliss): interpreted as a Christian symbol for the Trinity

3. Other Ashrams:

  • Ashram in Pune founded by Fr. Francis Acharya

  • Krupalaya Ashram (Karnataka)

  • Jyotiniketan Ashram (Uttar Pradesh)


🌍 Global Reach

Although the movement began in India, it has influenced Christian mystics and contemplatives worldwide, especially those involved in:

  • Contemplative Christianity

  • Interfaith dialogue

  • Christian–Hindu comparative spirituality

  • Universal Christ theology (e.g., Richard Rohr)


💬 Key Themes

ThemeMessage
Christ as inner guruChrist can be encountered as the indwelling divine Self
InculturationChristianity must be expressed in native cultural forms
Nondual mysticismMany ashram leaders embraced Advaita Vedānta alongside Christian faith
Interreligious encounterNot just tolerance, but mutual transformation and learning
Monastic renewalRevitalizing Christian monasticism through Indian models

🔥 Controversies and Criticism

  • Some orthodox Christians saw it as too syncretistic

  • Some Hindus were cautious of Christian missionary motives

  • Theological tensions: how to reconcile Advaita (nonduality) with Christian personalism

Still, the movement has been widely respected as a genuine and respectful spiritual synthesis, not proselytizing.


✨ Legacy

  • Inspired interspiritual dialogue long before it became mainstream

  • Helped reframe Jesus as a universal teacher and mystic

  • Opened new paths for Christian contemplative practice, especially in Asia


Would you like a comparison of Christian Ashram spirituality with traditional Benedictine monasticism or modern contemplative practices?

Wednesday, April 16, 2025

Protestantism is...winning?!


 


I find Alt Right gadfly Richard Spencer annoying (and he is annoying here, too) but I can´t help quoting his comment to the Catholic video above:

>>>The serious growth among “Protestants” is among post-Christian groups like Hillsong. Episcopalians, say, and Catholics have a similar downward trajectory. Interestingly, while the Anglican church is staffed by middle-age lesbians, this seems preferable to Catholicism, which is the domain of flamboyant gays.

LOL.