Showing posts with label Messalians. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Messalians. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 11, 2025

The return of the Messalians

 


Hesychasm goes full Messalian. We´ve been here before, haven´t we? I actually "discussed" this with AI recently...  

Saturday, December 17, 2022

Nothing to see here, dear Messalians

Credit: Daderot

From an old blog post: 

>>>I did get one insight, for all it´s worth, while reading the book. Johansons points out that medieval guilds, including powerful merchant guilds such as the Hansa, had initiation rituals featuring ordeals. The stone-masons had secret recognition signs, and many guilds had fictitious founder myths which the members were supposed to learn (perhaps as another sign of recognition). Thus, the stone-masons claimed that Moses was the first of their trade! 

>>>What this means, of course, is that we can lay all conspiracy theories about the Knights Templar to rest. The fact that the Templars might have had secret initiation rituals and “heretical” lore (“heretical” to the heresy-hunters of later centuries) doesn´t prove that they were a truly occult-heretical brotherhood. Their practices seem to have been medieval Catholic commonplaces! What a pity.

Exactly. Note also that the Knights Templar were accused of worshipping a severed head named Baphomet. Which sounds like a wordplay on John the Baptist (Ioannes Baptista) and Mahomet (the Turkish name of Mohammed). Bunk, of course. But note that the Knights Hospitaller, who were never accused of anything, openly venerated...wait for it...the severed head of John the Baptist! 

Note finally that Bernhard de Clairvaux, the original inspirator of the Knights Templar, had an almost "Tantric" bride-chamber mysticism. Which wasn´t considered heretical either at the time.

Are we on to something here?

Oh, and the Templars sometimes wore "Abraxas stones", but I´m sure that´s just a co-incidence!   

Tuesday, September 14, 2021

A different spaceship


"A Different Christianity" is a book published in 1995. The author, Robin Amis, is almost unknown, but his little band of followers have nevertheless written an extensive entry on him at Wikipedia (it wasn´t there a few years ago). Apparently, Amis (a convert to Eastern Orthodoxy) was an officially recognized "fellow traveler" of sorts to the monks at Mount Athos. His book is an extremely difficult read, and I don´t claim to have understood it completely myself. However, I don´t think it correctly reports Orthodox mysticism or hesychasm. A more charitable way of putting it, is that Amis wasn´t a *main line* Orthodox Christian. Religions, after all, can and do change...

Amis was a supporter of Boris Mouravieff, a Russian military officer who left Russia after the Bolshevik revolution (he had also served as Alexander Kerensky´s secretary) and eventually settled in Switzerland. In Constantinople, Mouravieff had met the idiosyncratic spiritual teacher G I Gurdjieff and his chief apostle (or ex-apostle or would-be apostle...) P D Ouspensky. Years later, Mouravieff published a three-volume work called "Gnosis" (Amis translated it to English) in which he attempted a synthesis of the Fourth Way (the teachings of Gurdjieff and Ouspensky), Eastern Orthodoxy and (perhaps) some form of Freemasonry, claiming that this was the true esoteric message of the Orthodox Church and the "Great Brotherhood". Amis frequently references both Gurdjieff, Ouspensky and Mouravieff, but note that of these, only the latter claimed to be Christian or Orthodox (no, some remark on the fly about the Fourth Way being "esoteric Christianity" doesn´t count). Amis clearly believes that there is a secret tradition within Christianity, but he admits that it might not be an unbroken chain going all the way back to the apostles, but a message that has disappeared and been reconstructed at several points in the past. Perhaps be believes that the Mouravieff phenomenon is the latest such reconstruction?

"A Different Christianity" does have a take on the Christian message which will strike many readers as very different from the usual one. Amis has a strong perennialist tendency (really a syncretist one), and often compares Orthodox hesychasm with Hindu yoga, including kundalini-related experiences (although he never uses that very term). He believes that there isn´t any difference between Western and Eastern system at their base, all of them representing the same "faith". Demons don´t really exist - they are really psychological projections of our own inner "demons". By this logic, could it be said that angels don´t exist either? The apocalypse is an allegory for the personal enlightenment of the believer. At one point, Amis says that we get saved by faith alone, and that works are products of our faith - the Protestant position. I find it ironic that Amis rejects the Gnostics from his irenic synthesis, while including the Hindus. Among the Church Fathers, he is especially interested in Clement of Alexandria, Origen and Evagrius of Ponticus, all three of whom were considered problematic from the standpoint of strict Church orthodoxy. More unusual sources of inspiration include alchemy and "The Book of Abramelin the Mage"!

Amis seems to reject the standard Christian notion that the human person is *both* a body and a spirit. Instead, he sees the spirit exclusively as the seat of the personality. This presumably explains his interest in Evagrius, who was often criticized for exactly this position himself. There seems to be a tension in the book between two strikingly different conceptions of mysticism (although I suppose the author may have seen them as two distinct stages). First, there is the idea that the goal of mysticism is to abide in a kind of almost nirvanic stillness ("noetic ascesis"), something that would make all persons strikingly similar, and presumably unaware of their physical bodies. Second, is the opposite idea of mysticism as Eros, as transformed sexual energy, indeed as "energy" in general, an energy which fills the physical body and eventually leads to a dramatic experience of the divine Light. In Orthodoxy, this experience is said to transform the physical body into an imperishable resurrection body (if only for a moment), but this aspect seems to be of no interest to Amis - yet, *that* is surely the original goal of hesychasm. It was precisely this "material" aspect of the new mysticism which made the medieval critics of the hesychasts suspect that they were really "Messalian" heretics. To Amis, the important thing is the spirit, and I suspect that the real goal is the noetic stillness, rather than the more dramatic manifestations, but it´s nevertheless intriguing (in a book about asceticism) that the author talks about sex and Eros so often, even to the point of quoting Allan Bloom!

I admit that my spiritual (and, I suppose, bodily) preferences are very different from those of "A Different Christianity", which may explain why my hydrogens weren´t magnetized by this gospel...

If you want to own all hard books about mysticism, you might consider adding this to your collection. 


Sunday, June 16, 2019

Byzantine studies have never been so boring




”Acta Byzantina Fennica” is the journal of the Finnish Society for Byzantine Studies. It accepts contributions in English, German, French, Italian and Greek but, alas, not Finnish. This is the 4th issue published in 2015. I admit that I found it incredibly boring and dragging. But then, I´m more into Byzantine theology than actual imperial history!

The most useful piece has the title “A Helping Hand from the Divine: The Triumphalist Iconography of the Early Theodosians”. After explaining how pagan Roman emperors used Herakles-Hercules as a potent divine symbol for their rule (and, I suppose, their wars), we learn that the most Christian and Orthodox emperor Theodosius the Great *also* used pagan iconography to justify his, including depictions of the very same Hercules. Theodosius also consciously modeled himself on Trajan, who was (of course) a pagan. It seems that Theodosius wasn´t as strictly Christian in his statecraft as he has often been made out to be by (surprise) Christian sources. This seems logical – after all, pagans existed all over the Roman world (including some pretty high places) long after Theodosius supposedly forced everyone in the Empire to become a Trinitarian or else. Could be of interest for further reviews…

Other pieces in these Acta include a short biography of Constantine Loukites, a court official at 14th century Trebizond (the Trapezuntine “Empire” was a rump Byzantine state established by the Komneni after the Latin capture of Constantinople), a weirdly eclectic article on Dyrrachium dealing with everything from topography to the Venetian salt monopoly, an article on Byzantine campaigns against Latins in the Peloponnese (both sides used Muslim Turkish mercenaries!), and a discussion about the surprisingly positive view of Cleopatra found in the “Epitome” of Ioannes Xiphilinos. His picture of the debauched Egyptian queen might have been tempered by direct experience of an actual female ruler, the Byzantine empress Eudokia Makrembolitissa. I admit I never heard of her until reading this little volume.

Nothing on the Messalians.

Friday, September 28, 2018

Among monks and Messalians





St Symeon the New Theologian (949-1022) was a controversial Orthodox monk and mystic in the Byzantine Empire. His life was almost coterminous with the reign of the famous (or perhaps infamous) emperor Basil II, known as the Bulgar-slayer to later generations. Today, St Symeon has been canonized by the Eastern Orthodox Church, but this development was by no means obvious during his lifetime. Indeed, Symeon was suspected of heresy and even banished for a period. Yes, he was supposedly a “Messalian”…

Hannah Hunt´s book is frankly boring, but it does give a good introduction to Symeon. Hunt doesn´t just discuss St Symeon´s mysticism, but also try to place him in proper historical and social context, both as regards Church history and more broadly within the Byzantine Empire of his time. Thus, we learn that Symeon was originally a court official, that he had substantial private wealth at his disposal even as a monk, and that monasteries in Byzantium were often politically oriented towards wealthy aristocratic patrons. The section on the role of monasticism within the Empire was interesting, especially since it showed that the stereotype of the Orthodox monk as a reclusive contemplative is just that (or perhaps an austere ideal seldom encountered in real life).

Symeon´s conflicts with Church officialdom were “all the usual ones”. As a strict ascetic, he naturally came into conflict with all the monks who had joined the monasteries for other reasons than the strictly spiritual. Indeed, many of Symeon´s monks actually rebelled against his authority and quite literally run away from the monastery! As a mystic with an intensely personal experience of God, Symeon de facto rejected Church officialdom, arguing that only people who had themselves seen God could possibly have authority, including the power to pardon sins. Symeon the New Theologian´s veneration of his spiritual father (teacher) Symeon the Studite (in the book referred to as Eulabes) was seen as highly aberrant by many in the Church. For starters, Eulabes was still alive when Symeon started to treat him as a saint! The mystic´s main opponent was the rationalist theologian Stephen the Synkellos, who had the ear of Emperor Basil II himself.

If this sounds suspiciously similar to the conflicts between Gregory Palamas and Barlaam the Calabrian 400 years later, well, that´s because the conflict *was* similar. Indeed, St Symeon the New Theologian is considered a forerunner to hesychasm, or perhaps even as an early hesychast himself. And yes, the hesychasts too were inevitably accused of the dread heresy of Messalianism!

Four stars, but be warned that this is a rather dry scholarly treatise (although perfectly understandable) of an almost Synkellite quality.

Monday, September 24, 2018

The heresy of heart




This is a collection of essays published in honor of Juana Raasch, a Benedictine nun and scholar of mysticism. I've only read one of the contributions, “Temple and Throne of the Divine Glory” by Hieromonk Alexander Golitzin. It's actually a critical essay. Golitzin, an Orthodox bishop and scholar, defends the Macarian Homilies against Raasch and Irenée Hausherr, a Jesuit who pioneered Western academic studies of Eastern Christian spirituality.

The Macarian Homilies, traditionally attributed to the 4th century Egyptian saint Macarius the Great, were written by an unknown mystic in Syria. Many still believe that “Pseudo-Macarius” was really a heretic, one of the so-called Messalians, condemned by several Church councils. This position was also taken up by Raasch and Hausherr. The Messalians were accused of repudiating the sacraments and Church hierarchy in favor of their form of mysticism. They were also believed to preach various bizarre notions similar to Manicheanism. Especially controversial was the idea that humans can literally see or experience God already in the present life. It's interesting to note that the later Hesychasts were accused of Messalianism. Apparently, Raasch and Hausherr also made a connection between Pseudo-Macarius and the modern charismatic revival (which they strongly opposed).

By contrast, Golitzin believes that Ps-Macarius was Orthodox, or at least orthodox enough not be condemned as an outright heretic. His article is essentially a defense of the Macarian Homilies against the charges of Messalianism. Since Golitzin supports the Hesychasts and believes you can see/experience God in this life, his defense of the homilies is really also a defense of Hesychasm, albeit he never explicitly says so.

I found the article interesting, and there are obvious tie-ins with Golitzin's other papers on the connection between Christian and Jewish mysticism. And while the Orthodox hieromonk Golitzin may not intend it, esotericists and “Messalians” probably would consider his ideas to be, shall we say, fruitful…

Saturday, September 22, 2018

Can Messalians park here, too?




A review of a sign which says "Parking Only for Zurvanites, All Others Will Be Towed" 

This is an extremely funny sign, since Zurvanism is an EXTINCT heretical branch of the Persian Zoroastrian religion. Thus, this particular parking lot will remain empty for a very long time...unless the Shaoshyant (or perhaps the Kwisatz Haderach) turn out to be a slightly jaded Zurvanite heretic!

On the corporeality of demons




This is an uncompleted work by Michael Psellus, the 11th century Byzantine philosopher, historian and courtier. Apparently, Psellus was also a magician and perhaps a crypto-pagan. At the very least, he was accused of so being by his enemies. “On the Operation of Demons” is a dialogue on demonology. Unfortunately, this edition says very little about the context of the work. I therefore didn't find it that interesting. Presumably, I must hone my knowledge of Byzantine magic in the future!

As already noted, “De Operatione Daemonum” is a dialogue between two characters, Timothy and Thracian. The latter is presumably a stand in for Psellus himself. The former is the audience substitute. Thracian often quotes a certain Marcus, a former black magician from Mesopotamia who converted to the true faith and entered a monastery. One wonders whether Marcus isn't also a stand in for Psellus? The first part of the dialogue contains bizarre attacks on the “heretical” Bogomils, here called Euchitae, who are supposed to breed and sacrifice children to conjure the demons. Their founder is called Manes the Maniac, presumably a reference to the Persian prophet Mani. Thracian's description of Bogomil cosmology is peculiar, thus he claims that this Gnostic group was actually worshipping the Demiurge!

As for the demons, Thracian divides them into several classes. It seems there are demons literally everywhere, from the sub-lunar region of space down to the oceans and subterranean caverns of Earth. The demons are said to be corporeal, but made of very thin or delicate matter. This makes it possible for Thracian-Psellus to explain why demons are afraid of swords and other metallic object (they really can feel pain), how they can be seen by the naked eye, or why they are capable of speaking to humans. Some demons are said to derive their energy from moisture, others breathe oxygen. In modern occult terms, Psellus seems to be describing “etheric” beings rather than “astral” ones. Angels are also corporeal, but here Psellus gets into deep waters, since the angels nevertheless are capable of moving through solid objects, which of course suggests the exact opposite (they are spiritual).

The editor of this edition, Youtube personality Tarl Warwick (alias Styxhexenhammer666), is interested in herbs and psychedelic drugs, and have therefore highlighted Thracian's story about a spirit-medium who had shamanic trances (including a supernatural raven!) after partaking of a certain herb on a high mountain. Personally, I'm more interested in Psellus' hard slanders against the Bogomils. Didn't they and other “Messalian” heretics consider God to be corporeal? Is that why Psellus has to attack them, to avoid being confused with them due to his own view about the corporeality of demons?

Clearly, there is a lot to unpack here…

Three stars.
“Don't try this at home, kids”.

Thursday, September 20, 2018

Beware of the accursed Gugliemites, my children



A review of "Encylopedia of Heresies and Heretics" by Charles S Clifton

Despite its name, this isn't really an “encyclopedia”, by which I mean a reference work of a scholarly nature. Rather, it's a popularized, non-scholarly work, similar in many ways to skeptical books on religion and superstition. It's not even particularly complete. Thus, there is no entry on Aphthartodocetism, for instance!

But sure, I admit that I didn't recognize all the “heresies” the author did include. How many have heard of Amalricians, Men of Intelligence or Gugliemites? More well known deviations from The Only True Faith include Arianism, Bogomilism, the Gnostic school of ribald reveler Carpocrates, the Hussites and the inevitable Messalians.

There are entries on some Catholic movements and persons who were at one time or another consider problematic: Joan of Arc, Beguins, Beghards, Flagellants, the Knights Templar and even the Franciscans. The author has also included information on well-known pagans, such as Hypatia, Julian the Apostate, Iamblichus and Celsus. And Apollonius of Tyana, whose main heresy I suppose was acting just like Jesus! The volume ends with a lengthy exposition on Witchcraft.

Not sure how to rate this material, but in the end I give it three stars. Not worthless, but perhaps not the best material around either.

Saturday, September 15, 2018

Communicatio idiomatum



The author of this short e-book, really a speech given at a scholarly conference, is a professor of patristics at an Orthodox seminary.

The speech discusses the Eastern Orthodox view of salvation as “theosis”, or the divinization of man. Sophrony of Essex was a British monk who published the works of Silouan the Athonite, a Russian ascetic who lived at Mount Athos in Greece. Both men emphasized “love of enemies” as an important part of the path to theosis.

Most of Veniamin's speech, however, deals with the tricky theological questions involved in the idea that man can become like God. Needless to say, the professor never solves them – it's no “solution” to say that man is divinized according to “God's energies” rather than “God's essence” (the “energies” are supposed to be uncreated), or to cock surely claim that, of course, human nature was hypostatically united with the Divine Person of Christ.

A strict Western theologian might wonder if the good professor isn't really a covert Monophysite heretic! After all, the notion of theosis does imply that human nature somehow becomes divine, which is surely verboten according to the Christological formula adopted at Chalcedon…

I know it’s the easiest thing in the world to criticize these old theological squabbles, but surely a notion such as theosis is at bottom mystical, so mystical that it can't *really* be comprehended through theological formulae…?

Saturday, September 8, 2018

A daimonic book




"Daimonic Reality" is a difficult book to review. It had an almost "daimonic" effect on me: paradoxical, Trickster-like, annoyingly incomprehensible - yet, somehow profound. I saw the book years ago on Amazon, but was misled by the subtitle into thinking that it was just another compilation of fairy encounters or monster lore. At the time, I couldn't care less. Recently, another Amazon reviewer noticed that I had belatedly struck up an interest in matters crypto-zoological and Fortean, and recommended Harpur's book as an advanced course. Of course, I understand what Harpur is saying, but I can't *relate* to his paradoxical, subjectivist and poetic form of spirituality. I'm apparently too little of a poet, and my favourite field guide to the Otherworld remains John Michael Greer's "Monsters"...

Patrick Harpur's spiritual vision is based on Neo-Platonism, Hermeticism and Jungianism. W B Yeats is frequently referenced. "Daimonic Reality" is an attempt to come to terms with fairies, UFO-s, lake monsters, ghosts and other paranormal entities. Who are they? Where do they come from? And what on earth do they want? Harpur believes that paranormal creatures are "daimons". They are temporary, personalized manifestations of an impersonal reality that could be called the World Soul, the collective unconscious or Imagination (in Coleridge's sense). Daimons are real, but not *literally* real. Rather, they are "daimonically" or metaphorically real. Daimons are both physical and spiritual, which explains why UFO-s, Bigfoot or fairies sometimes leave "physical" evidence, while nevertheless remaining highly elusive. Sometimes, daimons work through people, possessing them and forcing them to carry out paradoxical, seemingly meaningless actions, including hoaxes. Thus, Harpur regards crop circles as "daimonic", despite many such circles being the products of human pranksters.

The nature of daimons is fundamentally contradictory. They aren't literally real, but insist on being treated *as if* they were. Yet, if we forget the rules of the game and start regarding daimons as if they were *actually*, literally real, the result might be possession and madness. Daimons can be both divine and devilish, often at the same time. They are both "inside" us, as dream images or psychological archetypes, and "outside" us as seemingly objective entities. They are not our projections, however - in a sense, *we* are their projections or rather projections of the World Soul trapped in a literalism which is really just one perspective among many. With the aid of Imagination, we can overcome "single vision" and glimpse the real, underlying meaning of Nature. Even classical misidentifications (Venus is believed to be a UFO, a log is interpreted as a lake monster) can be daimonically real. From the perspective of Imagination, Venus could be both a dead planet and a goddess...or a UFO.

But what is the point of it all? To Harpur, daimons are the only mediators between us and the Divine. In a sense, they are the gods, initiating us into the World Soul. Daimons have an uncanny propensity to show themselves to non-believers or unimaginative people, as a potent reminder of the reality of the Otherworld. The worst thing we can do is to ignore them (as modern materialism does) or portray them as literal demons (as in Christianity). These are sure ways to provoke even more manifestations, often of a demonic ("evil") character.

Harpur also hints at an even higher reality, a marriage between Soul and Spirit. "Spirit" is the Divine, while "Soul" (or the World Soul) is the intermediary, astral region between Spirit and Earth. Of course, this hierarchical arrangement is simply Spirit's perspective. From the perspective of Soul, only Soul truly exists. Yet, Soul and Spirit somehow need each other. They seem to meet in Man, and at one point the author even suggests that the daimons want to become real, something they can only become by interacting with Man. "Their transformation is our self-transformation". This theme seems to be further developed in Harpur's later book "The secret tradition of the Soul".

"Daimonic Reality" did give me some insights. Anthropologists have often been bewildered by the contradictory nature of "Native" or ancient myths. How can the same cultures be so incoherent as to believe in several different creation myths at once? Nor are "primitive" religions entirely allegorical: a person possessed by a god, actually becomes that god. The concept of "daimonic" reality could be used to unlock a key or two in these contexts! Harpur points out that many modern Westerners also believe in four contradictory versions of an ancient myth. He is, of course, referring to the Gospels. If interpreted "daimonically", rather than literally, the Gospels suddenly make sense. Jesus the God-man is a daimonic man. Ironically, Harpur accepts the paradoxical Nicene creed, which defines Jesus as both God and man. In the author's opinion, Gnosticism and Arianism are forms of "literalism". If Jesus was literally divine, he can't have been really human - and if he was literally human, he can't have been really divine. The daimonic perspective makes it possible to claim that he was both. Of course, mainline Christians will nevertheless find Harpur's viewpoint too allegorical, mushy and polytheistic. Messalian, even!

I don't think "Daimonic Reality" is a suitable book for crypto-zoologists and monster-hunters. My impression of Forteans is that they *don't want* their little mysteries to be solved, since that would make the world (or their world?) incredibly boring. As for the crypto-zoologists, the literal-material world is sufficiently crazy for there to be *some* hairy ape-man somewhere, so they are not going home any time soon, either. That being said, I think Patrick Harpur's magnum opus will suit the Romantics, retro-Romantics, Jungians and (perhaps) the daimons just fine....

Western Tantra or Messalian heresy?




I bought this book mostly by mistake. Arthur Versluis is an American scholar specializing in esotericism. He probably believes in the stuff himself.

"The Secret History of Western Sexual Mysticism" is a general introduction to various esoteric groups in Europe and the United States which used sex to induce spiritual experiences (sex magic isn't included).

The author makes a broad sweep, from the Dionysiac orgies of ancient Greece to the writings of Alan Watts during the U.S. hippie era. Many of the sexually oriented mystics turn out to be "Christian" heretics, including the Messalians, the Carpocratians and the Cathars.

The author has a somewhat annoying tendency to depict the heresies as the real thing, yet he is forced to concede that Paul wasn't a sexual mystic... One chapter deals with 19th century American cults, including the Oneida community. Somewhat surprisingly, Versluis says nothing about the pseudo-sexual mysticism within "official" Christianity such as Bernhard of Clairvaux. Why not, I wonder?

The book ends with what amounts to a programmatic declaration from the author. He interprets sexual mysticism as a way of connecting with Nature, believes that men and women were equal in the sex-mystical groups, and that their goal was a special kind of gnosis and transcendence. In effect, the traditions described by Versluis are a kind of Western Tantrism. There, the book ends and the readers are left wondering what will come next...

Wednesday, August 8, 2018

Mysticism inverted? The strange case of Barlaam vs Palamas




I have several volumes of this series from Paulist Press, "The Classics of Western Spirituality". Frankly, they are very hard to digest. I guess you need a mystic mind to understand the writings, let alone the mind, of another mystic. Perhaps I'm just too rational? Or rationalist, as it were.

Gregory Palamas wasn't easy either, but his "The Triads" is nevertheless the easiest text I've encountered in this series. Palamas (who died in 1359) was a leading Orthodox churchman in the Late Byzantine Empire. He is most well known, or notorious, for his defence of the hesychasts, a group of monks who practiced a form of prayer that involved body postures and controlled breathing. (Modern admirers and detractors have likened it to yoga exercises.) The hesychasts claimed that this gave them a direct, mystical experience of God himself. Their practices were roundly condemned by Barlaam of Calabria, another leading Orthodox churchman, who was inspired by Catholic scholasticism. (I believe he eventually became a Catholic.)

On one level, this was the perennial conflict between the mystic and the philosopher, with Palamas being the former, and Barlaam taking the role of the latter. To Barlaam, God is unknowable "in essence", and all human knowledge of God therefore either takes the form of philosophical propositions, or mental experiences of created spiritual realites. Barlaam didn't deny that mystical vision is possible. However, he believed that this isn't a direct vision of God himself, but of something lower, something created by God especially for the purpose. The light that shone around Jesus at the Mount of Transfiguration was a created light, according to Barlaam. This light, moreover, is purely mental or immaterial. It can only be "seen" mentally, spiritually. Since all other knowledge of God is philosophical, Barlaam and his followers naturally emphasized studies of Greek philosophy (presumably Plato and Aristotle). Barlaam seems to have been honestly shocked by the hesychasts. In his opinion, they denigrated formal learning in an obscurantist fashion, claiming that they could actually see God, and therefore didn't need Greek philosophy. Barlaam also suspected the hesychasts of heresy, since a Gnostic group known as Messalians claimed to have the ability to see God with their material eyes, using some kind of excessive prayer technique. The Messalians were connected to, or identical with, the Bogomils, a group similar to the Cathars. The editor of this volume, who is sympathetic to Palamas, believes that Barlaam might have encountered some kind of fringe groups among the hesyschasts, rather than the real thing. Barlaam also argued, basing himself on Pseudo-Dionysius, that we cannot say what God is, only what he is not. This apophatic theology he took to mean, that God is unknowable to man, unless God decides to reveal himself through created things.

"The Triads" was Palamas' defence of hesychasm. Palamas believed that the spiritual exercises of the monks were more important than Greek philosophy which, after all, was polytheist and "confused God with demons". He also believed that Barlaam had a Platonist and dualist view of the relation between soul and body, since to Barlaam, only our most refined mental faculties are involved in mystical vision. Palamas emphasized the traditional Christian position that body and soul are a unity, that God created both, and that the body will be glorified after the second advent. If this is true, then it cannot be wrong to combine prayer and mystical vision with bodily postures and exercises. Both soul and body is involved in prayer. Palamas further held that the hesychasts actually did see God, and he even suggested that they saw him in a kind of "material" way. In the mystical experience, God transforms not only the mind of the mystic, but also the body, somehow turning it into a glorified body, albeit temporarily. Thus, the mystic does see God with his (glorified or deified) material eyes. (At least this is my reading of Palamas. And yes, it does sound a bit extreme!) Just as Barlaam, Palamas also argued on the basis of Pseudo-Dionysius, but in his interpretation the apophatic theology of negation is only the first stepping stone to a positive vision of God, a vision that is ineffable, yet very real, not simply "nothingness".

For some reason, the main point of contention between Barlaam and Palamas was the idea of "God's essence". Barlaam believed that humans can't experience or behold God's essence. Hence, the light seen by mystics must be created. A created being can only see other created beings. Here, Palamas had a problem. On the one hand, he admitted that God's essence is beyond human comprehension. On the other hand, however, he nevertheless believed that the hesychasts actually see God himself. He also connected this to the Transfiguration, arguing that since Jesus was both God and man, the light seen by the disciples at Mount Tabor must have been divine and hence uncreated. Palamas attempted to solve this problem with the now famous (or infamous) distinction between God's essence and God's energies. The energies are uncreated and hence part of God, and yet they are not his essence. The mystics experience these uncreated energies. Barlaam accused Palamas of bitheism, but even a dispassionate observer can sense a problem here. If God's energies are uncreated, how can they *not* be his essence? If they aren't his essence, what on earth are they? Palamas solution is to claim that things such as God's providence, prescience, will and virtues are energies, but not his actual essence. God is always something more, something beyond, his energies. I'm not sure whether this is a satisfying answer, philosophically speaking, but then, Palamas wasn't really a philosopher to begin with, but rather a mystic arguing with a philosopher. This presumably forced Palamas to use the philosophical notion of "essence", trying to make it serve his own position.

What makes the confrontation between Barlaam of Calabria and Gregory Palamas so intriguing, is that the roles of mystic and philosopher are strangely inverted in their case. It's Palamas the mystic who takes the "corporeal" position, while Barlaam the philosopher takes the more "spiritual" position. Somehow, we would expect the opposite. Also, it's Palamas who takes the more overtly theological and "Biblical" position, while most mystics tend to oppose the orthodoxies of their respective faiths, in favour of a more free wheeling approach. Indeed, Palamas is the only mystic I'm aware of who sounds strangely "physical", and very consistently challenges Platonizing or Gnosticizing notions of the primacy of soul over body. At the same time, it also makes him more extreme than mystics of other traditions, who don't believe in the bestowing of heavenly bodies during the mystical experience. (Outside the Biblical religions, few believe in a physical resurrection to begin with!)

Finally, let me note that this volume doesn't contain all of "The Triads", but only selections. However, the main lines of argument are obvious, and there is both an introduction and lengthy footnotes to aid understanding of the text.

If you really can understand mysticism...