Finland recently removed the swastika from their presidential flag. The Indian state of Bihar fills the gap...
The blog to end all blogs. Reviews and comments about all and everything. This blog is NOT affiliated with YouTube, Wikipedia, Microsoft Bing, Gemini, ChatGPT or any commercial vendor! Links don´t imply endorsement. Many posts and comments are ironic. The blogger is not responsible for comments made by others. The languages used are English and Swedish. Content warning: Essentially everything.
Finland recently removed the swastika from their presidential flag. The Indian state of Bihar fills the gap...
| Credit: Jacques63 |
| Credit: Sodacan |
Not sure how ChatGPT can know anything about obscure points of Swedish history and heraldry, so you probably have to do your own research on this one - not sure how, though. Still, an intriguing conversation! The problem: the greater coat of arms of Sweden (not shown above) include the French imperial eagle associated with Napoleon...which is very strange for a number of reasons. Or is it? The AI has the floor!
Short answer: no — there is no such universal rule in heraldry.
In fact, throughout heraldic history, arms were frequently altered, differenced, quartered, augmented, or even completely replaced.
The idea that “a coat of arms can never be changed” is a modern myth.
Here is how it actually works.
Heraldry is not one international law system.
It is a group of regional legal–customary traditions, mainly:
England & Wales
Scotland
France
Holy Roman Empire
Iberia
Italy
Each has different rules — but none include an absolute rule of immutability.
Medieval arms evolved by:
| Reason | What happened |
|---|---|
| Marriage | Quartering or impaling |
| Inheritance | Adding other arms |
| New titles | Augmentations |
| Cadency | Marks for younger sons |
| Royal favor | New charges added |
| Politics | Arms modified to show loyalty |
If arms were immutable, none of this could exist.
English royal arms changed repeatedly:
Norman lions
Plantagenet lions
French fleurs-de-lis added
French arms removed
Each reflected political claims.
So if the King can change arms, so can anyone.
What is fixed is:
A specific grant of arms defines one legal coat of arms.
You may not change that one specific design and still call it that same grant.
But you are allowed to:
receive a new grant
have arms differenced
combine arms
abandon arms
adopt new ones
Heraldry is a system of identity, not frozen art.
The idea of immutability comes from:
Victorian antiquarianism
20th-century hobbyist heraldry
a misunderstanding of legal identity
People confuse:
“you cannot falsify arms”
with
“arms can never change”
Those are very different things.
The true rule of heraldry is:
You may not misrepresent arms — but you may lawfully change, add to, or replace them through proper authority or custom.
That has always been the case.
Heraldry is a living legal language of identity, not a fossilized logo.
A coat of arms is meant to grow with a family — just like a name, a title, or a history.
If you want, I can also explain how this works differently in English, Scottish, and continental heraldic law — they handle change in fascinatingly different ways.
Yes — and that case is one of the best real-world demonstrations of why heraldry is about legal identity, not current political allegiance or territorial claims.
You are referring to Karl XIV Johan, born Jean-Baptiste Bernadotte, who had been made Prince of Pontecorvo by Napoleon Bonaparte in 1806.
Let’s unpack why he kept the eagle.
When Napoleon created Bernadotte Prince of Pontecorvo, he did two things:
He gave him a title
He gave him a coat of arms
That coat of arms — with the French imperial eagle — was not a claim to the territory.
It was the heraldic sign of a Napoleonic princely dignity granted to him personally.
Even after Bernadotte:
broke with Napoleon
renounced Pontecorvo
joined the Coalition
he did not cease to be the person to whom that dignity had once been granted.
Heraldry records what you are, not whom you serve today.
If Bernadotte had removed the eagle, he would have been falsely rewriting his own legal identity.
He was:
“Jean-Baptiste Bernadotte, formerly Prince of Pontecorvo”
That fact remained true forever.
Heraldry does not erase past legitimate honors — it accumulates them.
So his Swedish royal arms became:
Swedish kingship plus Napoleonic princely honor
This is exactly how heraldry is supposed to work.
European dynasties are full of this:
English kings kept:
French lilies
long after they no longer ruled France
German princes kept:
Polish eagles
Italian crowns
Burgundian devices
long after the lands were gone.
Because arms do not mean:
“I rule this land”
They mean:
“I hold this dignity in my lineage.”
Karl XIV Johan keeping the Napoleonic eagle sent a subtle but powerful message:
I am not Napoleon’s puppet —
but I am his equal.
It said:
I did not reject my past
I integrated it into my kingship
This made him a legitimate European monarch, not a Swedish puppet-king.
Heraldry is genealogical memory, not current propaganda.
You cannot undo:
a lawful title
a lawful grant of arms
by changing alliances.
Karl XIV Johan’s arms were telling the truth about who he was —
a Napoleonic prince who became a Scandinavian king.
And that is exactly what heraldry exists to preserve.
If you want, I can show you how Swedish heraldic law treated this and why the Riddarhuset accepted it without controversy — it’s a fascinating case.
Great — this is where the Karl Johan case becomes really illuminating, because Swedish heraldry handled it in a very principled, very medieval way.
We are dealing with Karl XIV Johan, formerly Jean-Baptiste Bernadotte, who brought into Sweden a coat of arms that included a Napoleonic imperial eagle — the personal emblem of Napoleon Bonaparte — even after he became Napoleon’s enemy.
Why was this accepted?
Swedish heraldic law, administered by the Riddarhuset (House of Nobility), follows the continental rule:
A coat of arms is a legal sign of personal dignity, not a declaration of political loyalty.
Once a person has legitimately received arms, they are:
hereditary
inalienable
permanent
unless revoked by a lawful authority.
Napoleon was the lawful sovereign of France in 1806.
His grant of the Pontecorvo arms was therefore valid forever, even if Napoleon later became Sweden’s enemy.
Sweden had no legal right to erase that.
When Bernadotte was adopted into the Swedish royal house in 1810, his foreign princely arms were:
not deleted
not replaced
not subordinated
They were quartered into the Swedish royal arms.
This was done officially when he became Crown Prince and later king.
In other words:
Sweden recognized the Napoleonic dignity as part of his lawful personal identity.
This is why the French eagle appears on:
Swedish royal standards
royal seals
Bernadotte dynasty heraldry
even after Napoleon’s fall.
By 1813, Bernadotte was fighting Napoleon — but he was doing so as:
a sovereign prince of European rank.
Keeping the Pontecorvo arms said:
I was not a usurper
I was not a deserter
I am a prince who changed alliances
That made him diplomatically legitimate to:
Austria
Britain
Russia
They dealt with princes — not turncoats.
At the Riddarhuset, nobles are registered by:
lineage
arms
legal dignity
not ideology.
Bernadotte’s arms were impeccable by European law.
Whether Napoleon was later hated was irrelevant.
Heraldry is not moral.
It is archival.
This reflects a very old principle:
A legitimate grant of arms can never be invalidated by later politics.
Only:
the original granting authority
or a lawful superior
can revoke arms.
Napoleon fell.
No one inherited the legal authority to cancel his grants.
So Bernadotte’s eagle was untouchable.
Karl XIV Johan’s coat of arms is a fossil of history.
It tells us:
where he came from
how he rose
what powers once recognized him
That is exactly what heraldry exists to do.
If you want, I can also show you how this same rule explains:
British kings still bearing French lilies
Russian tsars keeping Mongol symbols
Habsburgs keeping Burgundian lions
It’s all the same medieval logic.
Short answer: yes — grudgingly, conditionally, and legally — until 1814.
And that is exactly why Bernadotte’s Napoleonic arms remained valid.
Let’s be precise.
From 1804 (when he crowned himself Emperor) until 1814, the European powers did not treat Napoleon as an outlaw regime in the legal sense.
They:
signed treaties with him
exchanged ambassadors
recognized his titles
married into his dynasty
For example:
Austria married him to Marie Louise
Russia negotiated with him at Treaty of Tilsit
Britain signed peace treaties with him (Amiens, 1802)
This is full de jure recognition.
They hated him — but they accepted that he was the Emperor of France.
Because Napoleon was recognized as sovereign, he had the lawful right to:
create princes
grant coats of arms
establish noble houses
So when Napoleon Bonaparte made Jean-Baptiste Bernadotte Prince of Pontecorvo, that act had international legal validity.
Other states were not free to pretend it never happened.
This is the crucial legal point.
When Napoleon was defeated in 1814:
the Allies restored the Bourbons
but they did NOT nullify Napoleonic titles or marriages
they did NOT declare his acts void
Why?
Because that would have meant:
France had no legitimate government for 15 years.
That would have collapsed:
treaties
property rights
borders
marriages
So instead, they treated Napoleon as a lawful but defeated ruler.
By the time Karl XIV Johan became king of Sweden (1818), the European system had already decided:
Napoleon = lawful former emperor
His grants = valid historical facts
So Sweden was not “honoring Napoleon”.
It was recognizing legal continuity.
Europe did not say:
Napoleon was never legitimate.
They said:
Napoleon was legitimate — and we defeated him.
That distinction is why his heraldic and dynastic acts survived.
The Coalition denied Napoleon’s right to keep ruling.
They never denied his right to have ruled.
And that is why the French eagle still sits quietly inside the Swedish royal arms today — not as a political symbol, but as a legal fossil of European history.
This is a long but somewhat interesting video on the Wild Man, a character known from European folklore and mythology. There are also some excurses to North Africa and the Middle East. Yes, that would be Enkidu and the Biblical Esau, who was born hairy. In fact, there is even more than this to cover. For instance, legends of giants. Or even pygmies, if you want to go there. There is a Swedish/Finnish connection, too: a Wild Man is depicted in the coat of arms of Lapland.
But back to the video. The content-creator treats the Wild Man folklore as genuine reports of Bigfoot-like creatures. From this, he draws the conclusion that Bigfoot is more human-like than we´ve been lead to believe. Above all, Bigfoot is real and has been around since the dawn of time, perhaps as an alternate lineage of Homo?
Of course, to believe this, you have to first believe that modern Sasquatch reports are genuine. The Wild Man is virtually impossible to distinguish from *other* creatures of myth and folklore I assume the content-creator doesn´t believe are real. What about fire-breathing dragons, thunderbirds that can abduct adult moose, or enormously large lindorms in the Swedish countryside? There is zero evidence that such things ever existed, in fact, it´s not even clear whether they *can* exist. Yet, there are alleged eye witnesses (see my review of Hyltén-Cavallius´ 1885 book on the famed lindorm elsewhere on this blog).
It´s not clear to me that the modern Bigfoot reports are any better (or worse) than equally modern reports about even more fantastic creatures, such as thunderbirds, dog-men, or the Jersey Devil. And they, too, have analogues or even direct precursors in mythology and folklore. Are *they* real, too?
Ultimately, we have to ask: if the Wild Men (and, I suppose, Women) are real, well, where are they? There is no archeological evidence that such tribes of people persisted into the Middle Ages or Early Modern Period (yes, medieval and modern archeology is a thing). Nobody has found any bodies. The only thing we have are stories, many of which can be given alternative explanations. Yes, they are myths about liminality, not literal accounts of meetings with surviving Paranthropi. The extremely fierce "Gorillai" encountered by Hanno in Africa could have been chimpanzees. The se´irim are Hebrew demons, not hairy savages. Well, at least not according to Wikipedia!
And of course there is no evidence for dragons, werewolves or super-sized birds of prey either.
My main problem with (modern) Bigfoot is that people keep seeing the squatches everywhere across North America - including the plains of Kansas, at tourist hot spots, at highways, or even in suburbia - and yet there is almost no tangible evidence that the creature exists at all. Yet, scientists have tracked down rare but real animals such as the Bili ape. This suggests that we´re either dealing with an extremely rare species hyped by the media (so people think they see it everywhere), pure fantasy all the way down, or some kind of paranormal phenomenon.
The YouTube channel "Cabin in the Woods" is open to paranormal explanations. But the Wild Man mythology doesn´t depict a woodland sprite, but a flesh-and-blood creature with a rather broad range. And that´s surely the least likely explanation to this problematique.
![]() |
| An usurper flashing three crowns! |
So I decided to look into the origins and meaning of the three crowns shown in the Swedish coat of arms. Or coats of arms (in the plural). The reason? Denmark recently dropped the three crowns from *its* royal coat of arms. See an earlier blog post!
Finding out the symbolism of the three crowns turned out to be more difficult than I expected. In middle school, I heard a "folk interpretation" of the three crowns: they supposedly stand for Svealand, Götaland and Norrland. That is, the three geographical regions of Sweden. However, this can´t be the original meaning, since Sweden had a different territorial extension before 1809. Nor is it the official meaning even today. Indeed, the three crowns doesn´t seem to have any particular legal meaning. They are simply the traditional symbol of the Swedish kingdom, period.
Diving into the matter, it turns out that the 13th century king Erik Eriksson (later mockingly known as Erik the Lisping and Limping) used a royal coat of arms showing three crowned lions. This was obviously inspired by the Danish coat of arms. Of course, it doesn´t explain why there are exactly three lions (and hence crowns) rather than two or just one. I mean, only one man can be king! Erik Eriksson (king 1234-1250) was succeeded by Valdemar Birgersson (king 1250-1275) whose royal coat of arms shows three crowned leopards. Don´t even ask about the distinction between "lion" and "leopard" in heraldry!
Next in line is Magnus Ladulås (king 1275-1290), who used a crowned lion surrounded by three crowns on his seal. Then, it becomes more interesting. During the long reign of king Magnus Eriksson (1319-1364), the three crowns themselves became an emblem for...something. Apparently, there is a fresco in France (!) showing the coats of arms of various rulers and kingdoms represented at a 1336 summit in the papal enclave of Avignon to discuss the calling of a new crusade. The Swedish coat of arms is evidently a shield with three crowns. This could be the earliest evidence for its usage as a "national" symbol.
We also have coins minted by Magnus Eriksson´s government from 1350, showing a ring with three crowns. However, there is *some* confusion over the exact meaning of the crowns. At the height of his power, Magnus Eriksson was king of three kingdoms (Sweden, Norway and Scania). Is it possible that *this* is the meaning of the three crowns? By all accounts, there was nothing wrong with Magnus Eriksson´s self-confidence. He un-ironically believed himself to be born under a lucky star, claimed to be "God´s favorite", compared himself to king Solomon, etc. Together, his three kingdoms comprised the largest territory in Europe (nominally even including Greenland). Sounds like just the kind of person who would want to flash his success on coinage!
The first definitive evidence of the three crowns being used as a "national" symbol for Sweden (rather than as a personal symbol) comes from the reign of Albrekt of Mecklenburg (1364-1389). This is somewhat ironic, since Albrekt is universally seen as perhaps the worst monarch in Swedish history, an usurper whose German mercenaries plundered the country in the aftermath of the Great Plague. Albrekt was also supported by a brotherhood of Baltic pirates! However, it may have been precisely due to his somewhat shaky legal status that Albrekt wanted to become associated with the three crowns. It was royal propaganda to prop up his "legitimate" claim to the Swedish crown.
During the 15th century Kalmar Union, both Margareta and Erik of Pomerania used three crowns on their seals. However, I´m not sure if this is supposed to be a seal only used in Sweden or whether it was an informal symbol for the entire union, which did indeed comprise three realms: Sweden, Norway and Denmark (with the latter being strongest). In Sweden, the three crowns were certainly seen as a symbol for Sweden only. They were used that way by notorious on-off king and regent Karl Knutsson Bonde.
After the dissolution of the Kalmar Union in 1523, Denmark kept the three crowns in its greater coat of arms. The usual interpretation is that the three crowns in this context do symbolize the halcyon days of the Union. But that sounds unlikely, since both Denmark and Norway had their own fields in the coat of arms. So it probably does symbolize Sweden specifically and could therefore be interpreted as a veiled Danish claim on the Swedish throne!
Meanwhile, Sweden continued using the three crowns as a symbol for the Swedish kingdom. But - once again - why on earth are there *three* crowns in the coat of arms? There have been all kinds of weird speculations about this, my "favorite" being a 17th century claim that they stand for the Norse gods Odin, Thor and Frey, whose idols in the Uppsala pagan temple were supposedly crowned...yeah, whatever!
The most likely explanation I´ve come across is that the crowns stand for the three Magi, who were seen as three holy kings during the Middle Ages. The German town of Cologne (Köln) was an important place of pilgrimage during the High Middle Ages and supposedly housed the relics of the Magi. This could explain the obsession with *three* royal symbols: three lions, three leopards, three crowns. King Richard Lionheart had three lions in his coat of arms, and the mythological king Arthur was said to have had a blue shield adorned with three golden crowns.
So there you (probably) have it. It´s actually a symbol for Mesopotamian astrologers mentioned in a holy scripture of some obscure Jewish sect 2000 years ago. You know, the Gospel of Luke...
Everything is well in the world.
There is a persistent rumor, even in the mainstream media, that the Danish king Frederik X changed the royal coat of arms of Denmark as a direct response to Donald Trump´s territorial designs on Greenland. Even Danish pundits are pushing the rumor.
There is just one problem: it doesn´t seem to be true. The changes in question were recommended by a royal commission already on January 20, 2024. They were officially announced on December 20, 2024. Trump´s demand on Greenland came two days later and wasn´t widely reported until December 23.
The changes in the Danish royal coat of arms didn´t take effect until January 1, 2025. This probably fuelled the speculations that the change was a deliberate snub to Trump. The king apparently *did* call for increased unity between the various parts of the Danish Commonwealth in a New Year statement, which (of course) could be interpreted as a snub against both Trump and the premier of Greenland (who demands full independence for the island).
Finally, note that Frederik became king on January 14, 2024. It´s therefore logical that he would update the royal coat of arms, which was heavily anachronistic. The three crowns could be seen both as a symbol of the medieval Kalmar Union and as a veiled claim on the Swedish throne. Since Sweden and Denmark haven´t been enemy nations for two centuries, the presence of the three crowns in the Danish royal coat of arms looks frankly weird.
To sum up: when the three crowns (whatever they might mean) were removed, both the polar bear (Greenland) and the ram (the Faroe Islands) became more prominent. But Trump has made no demands on the Faroe Islands. So no, the change has nothing to do with Trump, but I can´t really blame the Danes for spreading the rumor...
You learn new shit every day. I´m a notorious "flag nerd", but I completely missed this one! The coat of arms of the British Indian Ocean Territory (BIOT) includes the Latin motto "In tutela nostra Limuria", which is supposed to mean "Lemuria in our trust"!
Yes, Lemuria. The imaginary continent of Lemuria, here with the more unusual alternative spelling Limuria. The above illustration is from the website of the BIOT administration.
Just this Thursday, the UK announced that they will hand over control of the BIOT (a.k.a. the Chagos Archipelago) to Mauritius...but the large US military base at the main island of Diego Garcia will remain for another 99 years. So nothing really changed. Except, I suppose, that this peculiar coat of arms is soon history...
Interesting introductions to Nazi symbolism, including SS symbols. Note that the "rune of death" is identical to the later peace symbol used by the CND! Probably a co-incidence, right?
| Credit: Richard Managr |
This is probably the most obscure book I will ever review here on my blog.
"Slovenske Mestske a Obecne Erby" is a book by Jozef Novak, published in 1967 in Bratislava by Slovenska Archivna Sprava. It was the first volume in a series called "Edicia Pomocne Vedy Historicke a Archivnictvo".
Yes, folks, we're talking about a book published in Communist Czechoslovakia.
The book deals with heraldry, more specifically the coats of arms of Slovak towns and villages. It's written in a relatively accesible style (at least if Slovak is your first language), but the author is obviously a scholar. The notes abound with references to archival sources, including medieval documents, seals and earlier works on Slovak heraldry. Or rather Hungarian ditto, since Slovakia was an integrated part of the Hungarian Kingdom until 1918.
The author explains the evolution of Hungarian heraldry in some detail. Originally, Hungarian towns used coats of arms based on those of the ruling dynasty (the House of Arpad). Later, this became impossible due to frequent dynastic conflicts and the rise of powerful local rulers. To feign neutrality, the towns therefore preferred to show patron saints on their coats of arms. A third phase saw the emergence of distinct town symbols, beholden neither to the ruling house nor the Church, reflecting the increased power and confidence of the towns during the Early Modern Period.
Apparently, the coat of arms of Banska Stiavnica is unique in Slovakian history, since it adopted a distinct town symbol already during the 13th century, no doubt because of its immense economic importance (silver mining).
During the 19th century, coats of arms were seen as antiquated and "feudal", and the local governments often stopped using them altogether. Those who continued using them often didn't know what coat of arms was the right one!
An administrative reform in 1902 tried to remedy the situation, even decreeing that all town seals in Hungary should be remade by the same person, Ignac Felsenfeld. A special commission studied relevant archival material to decide on the "right" emblems. As a heraldry nerd, Jozef Novak naturally believes that the earliest coats of arms are more "pure" than later ones, while the commission rather preferred the latest designs, since towns during earlier periods often used strikingly similar symbols.
Since the colors of many coats of arms were unknown (probably because they were only used as symbols on wax seals), the commission decided what colors to use, showing a strong preference for silver charges on blue shields, making Hungarian heraldry look weirdly uniform.
The book doesn't deal with developments under Communism, when many Slovak towns and localities unofficially kept their coats of arms - or changed them in very unheraldic ways (although it's possible this didn't happen until after the book was published).
I happen to know that many Slovak towns use the "wrong" coats of arms, compared to the ones Novak has unearthed from the archives. Often, the devil is in the details, as when Pezinok's coat of arms shows Mary on a green shield, when the actual motif should be Anna holding an infant Mary on a blue shield...
Or perhaps not, since the Catholics insist that the lady on the escutcheon *is* the Virgin Mary, while the Lutherans apparently interpreted her as Anna! This per the current website of Pezinok.
The color is still wrong, though.
Perhaps it's time for another commission?