Showing posts with label Atheism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Atheism. Show all posts

Friday, November 6, 2026

Israel Only Full of It Preterists? (Round two)

 


It´s been a couple of years, but here we go again! I haven´t even bothered reading all of it, but in case you are an extreme "Judaizer", I suppose you might need to hear this...

The weird Israel Only of Jason DaCosta

Thursday, November 5, 2026

Liar, lunatic or Appolinarian?

 


A clever argument against C S Lewis´ Trilemma, arguing that it´s implicitly Apollinarian. And Appolinarianism is, ahem, an ancient heresy...

Check mate. 

Sunday, November 1, 2026

Relics of a Church?

 


An attack video on the Catholic Church and their relics, posted by an ex-Protestant atheist on Reformation Day?! LOL. 

Thursday, October 29, 2026

Halloween haunting

 

Credit: kallerna

So I just watched the movie "A Haunting in Venice" from 2023. It´s apparently loosely based on an Agatha Christie novel, "Hallowe´en Party". Which obviously explains why Swedish television choose to show it now. I admit the movie was quite good. 

The year is 1947. The Belgian detective Hercule Poirot lives in Venice, Italy and refuses to take any new cases. Naturally, he is tricked into a situation anyway. In the film, Halloween is celebrated even in Venice. Poirot, a skeptic and atheist, participates in a séance in a supposedly haunted house. He exposes the medium as fake. Naturally, the hoaxer is killed in gruesome fashion and the game is on. 

The rest of the plot is very Agatha Christie-esque: everyone´s guilty of something, more murders follow and the full story turns out to be quite complex. You have to pay attention, rather than going into the kitchen and make a coffee! And yes, some of the characters are pretty colorful.

Since it´s a Halloween-themed flick, there is a supernatural element to the story. Poirot has an explanation (I actually suspected that the passing reference to Mithridates would turn out to be significant) but in the end, we are left to think that maybe some of the hauntings were real after all...

That´s probably all I can say in a short review (muh-hah-hah). Happy Halloween, kids. 

Monday, October 19, 2026

Memetic

 

Credit: Mandana-r

This isn´t funny, but I predict that this will become a very popular Protestant / atheist meme for at least 20 years. Link to X below.

Priest in Ecuador gets killed by falling crucifix

Sunday, October 11, 2026

The heretics are leaving

 


The Mormon Church is shrinking in membership, at least in the United States. About 50% of people raised Mormon leave the Church later in life. And most of these become "religiously unaffiliated" (perhaps atheists?) rather than joining some other Christian Church. 

Below, I also reproduce the two most interesting critical comments to the video above. 

It struck me that the Mormons could still "save the day" by mass immigration to the United States (perhaps Utah) from other parts of the world, where their Church is still growing... 

xxxxx

LucasGuerreiro says:

This post is a perfect example of how legitimate research can be used to promote a misleading narrative. First, the Pew Research Center study examined religious retention in the United States, not worldwide. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is a global religion, and American trends cannot automatically be applied to millions of members living across the world. Second, while the decline in retention from 70% to 54% is real, the claim about young women is misleading. Pew found no statistically significant difference between younger women (49%) and younger men (54%) in retention rates. Third, the study does not establish that Church teachings on sexuality, gender roles, finances, or Republican politics caused people to leave. These are the author’s personal interpretations, not scientific conclusions supported by the research. Correlation is not causation. Now, let’s look at the bigger picture. According to the Church’s latest official statistical report, released in April 2026, worldwide membership reached 17,887,212 at the end of 2025, an increase of 377,431 members (2.16%) in just one year. The Church also reported 385,490 convert baptisms in 2025, almost 25% more than in 2024. Worldwide congregations increased to 32,046. And here’s another finding from the same Pew study that this post conveniently ignores: 69% of American Latter-day Saints report attending religious services at least weekly, compared with just 25% of American adults overall. Of course, increasing membership does not eliminate legitimate concerns about retention, and official membership totals are not the same as active attendance. Every person who leaves deserves to be heard and treated with respect. But acknowledging challenges is very different from portraying a worldwide, growing religious community as a failing institution. The Church is not defined by American political divisions, and its mission is not to represent Republicans, Democrats, or any political ideology. Its mission is to invite all people, everywhere, to come unto Jesus Christ. We should welcome serious research. But we should also distinguish scientific evidence from ideological commentary.

xxxxx

andrewsuryali8540 says:

Don't wanna rain on everyone's parade, but let's just say that the LDS is rich enough to be able to commission a more detailed and focused study on their own people, and depending on how Monson wants to treat Nelson's legacy, this might come out in the next several months as either leaks or actual publications... Anyway, what looks to be the case isn't that LDS members are becoming more open to liberal ideas. In many cases it may be the opposite. See, in 2018 Nelson tried to rebrand the LDS to try to make it look more "Christian non-denominational", at least in the way he understood it. He also allowed the loosening of some of the purity laws in trying to make the LDS look "less weird". The problem is that this was done almost immediately in the wake of a massive WILDLY POPULAR multibillion-dollar "proud to be Mormon" campaign where the church asked its members to double down on their Mormon identity. Then starting in 2020 there was an acceleration in the rate of members leaving. The main reason behind this isn't Mormons becoming more liberal-progressive and getting disenchanted by their church's conservativeness. The rate of more progressive youngsters leaving didn't really change. What changed was that more of the older generation and the LESS progressive young women started leaving in droves. The main culprit among the older generation is "loss of distinctiveness". These are people who have invested decades of their lives on being Mormons, who had just recently been "rewarded" by their church with a confirmation of their efforts and a public doubling-down of their identity. Then suddenly they were told to pretend they were regular Christians and asked to try to blend in with the very people who had rejected and tried to marginalize them all their lives. For many that was the last straw. The younger, more conservative women also have a similar complaint. They had also invested their lives into upholding the purity culture, had been rewarded, then had their lifelong effort annulled by Nelson. If you're a Mormon girl who had felt vindicated by not having piercings in 2018, then you'd feel utterly betrayed in 2025 when the leadership said it's OK for boys to date girls with piercings. So it isn't that the Mormons are becoming more open to liberal ideas and leaving because of that. Rather, it's Nelson's misguided effort to "normalize" the LDS within Christianity that's alienating the most hardcore Mormons and making them leave. It's actually really strange that he still made that mistake after seeing the example of the RLDS as they shed more than 60% of their members while transitioning into becoming the Community of Christ.

Saturday, October 10, 2026

A question of control

 


"The Heretic" (2024) is a bizarre American film. It´s actually a kind of philosophical or even theological horror film. I admit that I have no idea what the message might be. 

The main character Mr Reed (starred by Hugh Grant of all people) is a crazy, murderous atheist who captures two female Mormon missionaries in a maze-like house. His intentions are unclear, but revolve around attempts to prove that all religions are fake. Their real purpose is control. During the confrontation, it turns out that the Mormon girls are really skeptics. One of them claims that near-death experiences are caused by purely natural causes, while the other says that prayer is purely metaphorical or psychological in nature. Before they visit Mr Reed, the girls discuss sex and pornography.

The atheist arguments sound more convincing than the simplistic faith the missionaries pretend to have at the outset. However, I also get the impression that Reed might not be an atheist in the strict sense. He believes that all religions (or at least the "Abrahamic" ones) go back to a kind of primordial revelation, the exact nature of which is left unclear. It also seems that he is trying to convince himself, first and foremost, that all God-belief really is bunk. Note also that Reed has turned into a kind of cult leader. His personal paranoia is tied to Simulation Theory, which could be interpreted as Gnostic. Maybe the house of horrors is a "simulation" all its own?

And yes, I did notice the allusion to blood atonement and the in-house *skeptical* joke about Mormon "magical underpants" (but here used by the Mormons themselves). The usual pun on Moroni´s name ("Moron I") is also included. 

"The Heretic" ends with two miracles, but these are less convincing (I´m tempted to call them deus-ex-machina) than the bulk of the movie, making me wonder if they were tacked on simply to make the production somewhat less shocking to a religious audience. Well, at least it manages to portray consistent atheism-materialism as meaningless, brutal and absurd! 

Not sure if anyone really did become a heretic due to this flick. 

Friday, October 9, 2026

The Luciferian impulse

 


Something´s wrong when a self-awoved Satanist sounds more rational than...I don´t know...anyone else in the United States in 2026? Note that the Satanist was simply reciting the usual American message of individualism, rationalism and secularism. Oh, and the article seems to confuse the Church of Satan with the Satanic Temple...

City council member hails Satan in Iowa 

Monday, September 14, 2026

Paradigm shift

 


It´s happening, fam. The Second Religiosity is now. Make of this content whatever you wish. 

Thursday, September 10, 2026

Complete shocker: Free will is...real?!

 


Speaks for itself. Free will denial has always been one of the most silly cyber-atheist talking points, so I suppose it´s a good thing for those guys that we know have objective scientific evidence (as opposed to, you know, mere personal anecdotes) that Voluntarist Free Will really does exist, I mean, duuuude, who knew?!

Friday, September 4, 2026

Deceiving spirits

 


Here we go again. I actually wondered about this myself: if even the Anti-Christ makes miracles, how can miracles prove the Catholic Church? Or Christianity in general? How do we know *they* aren´t the Anti-Christ?

From MythVision, commenting the recent conversion/reversion of YouTube personality Joe Schmid to Catholicism. 

Thursday, August 27, 2026

Social experiment

 




I admit that I never heard about the famous Princeton philosopher Joe Schmid before. Perhaps because he is just a random guy on YouTube who happens to study philosophy somewhere at Princeton? Recently, Schmid shocked his fellow atheists/agnostics by converting (or strictly speaking reverting) to Catholicism. Or did he? 

Some suspect he is just trolling. His video does look unserious, but perhaps he is just the hyperactive autistic type? Anyhow, this is the current drama on YouTube right now. 

Do I care? Nupe. But in case you´re interested, the first video above is Schmid´s conversion story, while the second is a critique from Derek of MythVision. 

Saturday, August 8, 2026

Britt Hartley´s dangerous idea

 


I somehow managed to miss this Britt Hartley video. It´s called "The ugly side of atheism / 5 things I hate about atheists (as an atheist)". The most sensational move is when Hartley uses secular psychology and evolutionary theory *to undercut the claims of atheists to rationality*. How can atheism be "rational" if our senses are fundamentally unreliable? Exaaactly...but this is of course a popular *Christian* argument against atheism! Here used by a fellow atheist to cut the perfectly "rational" (male) on-line atheists down to size.

I suppose we could call "Britt Hartley´s dangerous idea"...

The main reason, I think, why Hartley is so controversial in (male) atheist on-line spaces is that she "wants to both have the cake and eat it". In a very real sense, she wants spirituality without Spirit and religion without God. Differently put, she wants to keep the social and psychological dimensions of religion without the metaphysics. I think her (male) atheist detractors (and presumably her religious detractors, too) see this as a kind of LARP. A quasi-religious LARP, to be exact.

Could it work on a mass scale? Maybe. After all, civic religion is a thing. Still, since the LARP is supposedly rooted in our most basic psychological make-up, sooner or later the participants might feel drawn to actual religion, seeing it as "the real thing" or "the missing ingredient". Why not assume that a psyche molded by evolution to "feel" or even "see" Spirit *actually feels or sees Spirit*? The metaphysics are real. Especially if the LARP is very self-consciously modelled on explicitly religious communities (say Christian ones). I think Hartley´s (male) opponents see her as in some objective sense too "spiritual" or religious.

As usual, there is also an discussion on how atheism is male-coded (it´s cold, hard, rational yada yada) whereas religion and spirituality are female-coded. Hartley never says it out loud, but I think she suspects that her male critics see her as "the weak and confused woman" who can´t let go of her emotional support blanket.

Hartley has controversial takes on a few other topics, too. Would secularism really turn the United States into "Norway"? (I assume she means Sweden!) Do atheists really have higher IQ than religious people? 

Could be interesting to watch. 

Tuesday, August 4, 2026

The Spinoza method

 


OK, this is going to be a rant, but whatever...

"The Spinoza method" seems to be just another version of the OTF. And probably even more silly, since it presupposes from the start that all religious scriptures should be interpreted literally (does that include "The Gospel of Thomas"?) and are obviously fake. But the atheist narrator admits that billions of people believe in it. So clearly it isn´t *obviously* fake, is it? The point of the rhetoric is obvious: the small minority who has seen through it are Brights. And everyone else is an idiot. I suppose that must be a wondeful thing to hear when you´re in senior high or college (where most American atheists took up their atheism). Smart people! LOL.

Since the main point of the video is to attack Christianity, it´s actually quite funny that the last segment of this video comes across as an evangelization tool for...wait for it...Zoroastrianism! Now, Zoroastrianism is probably the religion I most would *like* to be true, so the idea that Jesus is really the Shaoshyant does have a certain intrinsic appeal. But no, I don´t believe it either. 

A competent Christian apologist should be able to respond to this video. Sure, the response might be "wrong", but I think it could be made to sound convincing. Simply presupposing that you´re right won´t help you there, buddy.

Now, do Woke.