Showing posts with label Scotland. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scotland. Show all posts

Thursday, October 29, 2026

Sekten

 


När kommer Sekten att störtas? Woke-vansinne från Skottland. Idag. Inte 2010-talet (efter Kristus).

Muséer tar bort mumier: "Har inte samtyckt"

Tuesday, October 20, 2026

Insular speculations

 


A scholarly video on YouTube concerning the languages of pre-Celtic Britain and Ireland. Or rather speculations about what they could have been. 

One rather obvious idea is that the pre-Celtic populations of the British Isles spoke non-Indo-European languages, the Celts being the first Indo-European people(s) to reach the area. Pictish may have been a late survival of these non-IE tongues. Another speculation is that there was an earlier Indo-European migration to the isles. This branch of the IE language family would be long extinct.

Perhaps more attested is the notion of a vast Sprachbund regrouping Celtic, Berber and Vasconic languages, perhaps also West African ditto. Linguists have long noted peculiar grammatical similarities between the Celtic and Berber languages, yet they don´t seem closely related and are placed in entirely different language families.

It also struck me when watching this video that all of this is really "luxury knowledge" of interest only to a very narrow group of specialists or nerds. Throughout most of human (pre)history, people simply spoke whatever language they happened to have and got on with their lives (or migrations) rather than analyzing its syntactic structures...

We are WEIRD. And not a little insular!

Thursday, August 27, 2026

Vindicatory

 


The distinction between "public" and "private" in this video about revelation is just a sleight of hand trick. Weren´t most revelations given to Paul and John (at Patmos) "private"? Wasn´t Fatima "public"? But RZ (the content-creator) isn´t a Catholic. The ministry of Jesus was a "public revelation", but why didn´t the resurrected Christ show himself to his enemies or to the indifferent? In a certain sense, his resurrection was therefore also "private". Und so weiter. 

He´s right about the NDEs, though. 

Friday, July 10, 2026

Stray feathers

 


I learned something new today. Did you know that the Indian National Congress was founded by a Scotsman? Yes, Allan Octavian Hume. He was a Theosophist. Of course he was a Theosophist! See link below. 

Allan Octavian Hume

Friday, May 8, 2026

Whatever

 


So what happened in the recent British (regional/local) elections was that Reform replaced the Tories, and the Greens replaced Labour. And therefore...what? Here´s a prediction: No change. Next question!

Tuesday, April 21, 2026

Irish ale

 


A one-hour video about cryptids from the British Isles. As in: Britain and Ireland. Minus the Loch Ness monster and ABCs, so these are strictly speaking the *other* cryptids. It turns out to be a rather bizarre collection of tall tales. White dire wolves clearly inspired by "Game of Thrones", blue quaggas, a centaur running across the highway at night, a feline with four tusks and twelve fingers on each foot...you get the picture. 

The Irish guy in the video is a bit too credulous. What are the chances that a report about a horned hippo from a lake which can´t be located on any map isn´t a hoax? The blue quagga was only seen once - by a notorious con man - so the specimen on display in the UK c/o the same con artist was probably just a regular horse (with paint on it?). The "earth-hounds" that burrow in graves and eat the dead are obviously mythologized badgers, while the oversized "king hares" may actually be real hares. Some rabbits can actually grow to large sizes, so why not other Lagomorphae? 

More intriguing are sightings or remains of animals believed to be extinct, either in general (Irish Elk) or on the British Isles (wolves, bears). And then there´s the Wildman, the British "Bigfoot", which (who?) is indeed very difficult to take seriously, although I suppose it *is* interesting that legends of giants and pygmies exist all over the world. But without fossil remains or actual relict populations, a folkloric explanation is more likely. Well, I hope!

Good luck with this material. And be careful with the ale, guys. 

Monday, January 19, 2026

Ögonstenar

 


Det ligger säkert en del i detta, men det finns trots allt en viktig skillnad mellan Kina och EU. Nämligen att Kina har Folkets Befrielsearmé. Vad har EU? Öppna gränser? Grön energi? Könsbytarlagar? EU kan inte ens fatta beslut utan att fjäska för en viss Viktor Orbán...

I slutändan kommer det att sluta med krig. Macron var på rätt spår redan förra året då han erbjöd sig att utsträcka det franska kärnvapenparaplyet till hela Europa. Inklusive Tyskland. Och Danmark? Då vore det verkligen slutfjäskat.  

Slutfjäskat: Så kan Europa slå tillbaka mot Trump

Sunday, January 18, 2026

The Great Divorce

 


Maybe it really is time for Europe to break with the United States. Or at least become as independent as possible in terms of technology, the military, energy, and so on. Let´s say the Trump Republicans are defeated later this year in the midterm elections. So what? Vance can still win the presidentials in 2028. And the "isolationists" retake Congress. 

Unless the Trump-Vance faux populism is completely rooted in favor of the old bipartisan system dominated by Democrats and Neo-Cons (both equally beholden to the transatlantic link), there will always be a risk that the next US administration will turn its back on Europe. And nothing at presents point to a reset being possible. Or - frankly - even desirable.

It´s time for France to step forward and shoulder its responsibilities. 

Two other things. The UK will probably become a close Trump ally when Farage becomes PM after a Reform Party landslide victory. However, this little problem can probably be dealt with rather efficiently by France simply reactivating its Auld Alliance with Scotland. So I wouldn´t be too concerned about it.

It also struck me that Europe could become a Chinese ally if China stops the Russian war in Ukraine on terms at least somewhat favorable to the Ukrainians. This would finally make China a great power with a good position to defeat the United States in a shooting war. Not to mention a trade war. I´m amazed that the Trump administration doesn´t seem to see this. Do they want to lose Europe to the "Chinese Communist Party"? The guys in DC clearly aren´t playing 4D chess! More like solitaire. Or perhaps a long con... 


Sunday, January 4, 2026

Within our lifetime

 


Will this happen within our lifetime? The European Union (with Scotland as the newest member-state) will ally with Canada against the United States. There will be US attacks against some Canadian province (Alberta has oil) and Greenland. Russia will ally with the United States, at least diplomatically. 

China and Russia will eventually have a fallout, leading to a shooting war between them...or between the Chinese and India (an ally of Russia). Euro-Canada will ally itself with China against Russia. The Russians will effectively lose control of Siberia to Beijing. 

Just speculating, of course. But I wouldn´t be surprised if the "prophecy" above comes true!   

Thursday, January 1, 2026

Thursday, October 23, 2025

Where is king Charles?

 


I actually wondered about this myself. Sure, the British monarch has no effective power anymore, but since the Brits are high on formalities, I wondered if the split in the Anglican Communion could still impact him in some embarrassing way. But it seems the monarch is just a rubber stamp these days for decisions taken by the Church of England itself. So nah, Charles neither can nor will do anything. 

Note also that the king is only the Supreme Governor of the specifically English Church, not the Anglican Communion as a whole. According to Wiki, he´s not even the head of the Anglican Church in Scotland!

Everything is well in the world. Or no?    

Tuesday, August 5, 2025

The David Hume Probleme

 


Also know as "the Redditor predicament". Tonight´s ChatGPT essay or "How I convinced the AI that my take on David Hume is the correct one". 

How could David Hume have formulated an "invincible" argument against miracles based on the regularities of nature, if he was a radical skeptic who believed that we can´t really be certain of the regularities of nature in the first place?

Excellent question—and one that philosophers have wrestled with for centuries. You’ve zeroed in on a deep tension in David Hume’s thought: How can someone who radically doubts the certainty of causality and nature’s regularity also argue so confidently that miracles are practically impossible?

Let’s unpack this step by step.


⚙️ Hume’s Argument Against Miracles (Simplified)

Hume’s most famous claim is this:

“No testimony is sufficient to establish a miracle, unless the falsehood of that testimony would be more miraculous than the fact which it endeavors to establish.”
— An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, Section X

In plainer terms:

  • We believe in the laws of nature because we have consistent, repeated experience of them (e.g., gravity, death being irreversible, etc.).

  • A miracle is a violation of a law of nature (e.g., resurrection).

  • Therefore, any claim of a miracle is competing with all of our experience of how nature works.

  • Unless the evidence for the miracle is stronger than this mountain of consistent experience, it is always more reasonable to reject the miracle.

This argument seems “invincible” because Hume builds a probabilistic wall around the idea of nature’s regularity. Miracles are, by definition, improbable, and so they can never overcome the prior probability of nature continuing as usual.


🤯 The Problem: Hume's Radical Skepticism About Causality

Here’s where things get tricky.

In Section VII of the same work, Hume argues that:

We have no rational basis for believing in necessary causal connections in nature.

We only expect the sun to rise tomorrow, fire to burn, and stones to fall, because they’ve done so in the past. But this expectation is habit, not logical certainty. There's no deductive or a priori reason why the future must resemble the past.

So now you’re asking:

🧠 “If Hume thinks our belief in nature’s regularity is based only on habit, not reason... then how can he argue so strongly against miracles on the basis of regularity?”


🧩 Possible Answers and Interpretations

1. 🧱 The Pragmatist Interpretation

Hume was a psychological skeptic, but a practical naturalist.

  • He admits we can’t prove the laws of nature through reason.

  • But he also believes we must live as though they are regular, because human psychology demands it.

  • So his anti-miracle argument is not about metaphysical certainty, but about what we should believe, practically, based on human experience.

In short: “We can’t be certain about nature’s laws—but we are more certain of them than of any claimed miracle.”

This makes Hume a kind of epistemic probabilist: he doesn’t need certainty, only relative confidence.


2. 🔄 The Double Standard Critique

Some critics say Hume cheats:

  • He uses skepticism to undermine arguments for God or miracles.

  • But then he drops the skepticism when defending naturalism or science.

So you could argue that Hume is inconsistent: he treats the regularities of nature as solid when attacking miracles, but elsewhere he says they're not solid at all.

This is sometimes called the "asymmetry problem" in Humean interpretation.


3. 🧮 Bayesian Interpretation

Some modern philosophers (e.g. John Earman) try to formalize Hume’s argument using Bayesian probability:

  • The prior probability of a miracle is extremely low.

  • The likelihood of a person misperceiving, lying, or being mistaken is much higher.

  • Therefore, even good testimony rarely raises the posterior probability of a miracle above the threshold for rational belief.

This gives Hume’s argument a modern statistical form—even if he didn’t write it this way himself.

But again, it assumes that we can assign reliable probabilities to the "laws of nature"—which Hume’s own skepticism seems to undercut.


🧾 Summary: So Is Hume Contradicting Himself?

✅ Consistent if you read him as a psychological pragmatist:

He’s not claiming certainty about nature—only saying that testimony for miracles is always weaker than the weight of accumulated experience.

❌ Contradictory if you hold him to strict epistemic standards:

If he truly believed we can’t rationally justify the regularity of nature, then it’s hard to see how he can rule out miracles on that very basis.


🔄 Final Thought: Two Humes?

Some philosophers talk about "two Humes":

  1. The radical skeptic, who tears down causality and induction.

  2. The cautious empiricist, who gives us rules for practical belief.

His argument against miracles makes sense if he’s wearing the second hat—but not the first.

So, perhaps the best answer is that Hume wasn’t aiming to be perfectly consistent across all contexts. He was offering a devastating challenge to supernatural claims using the tools of everyday experience—even if those tools aren’t metaphysically secure.


Would you like a breakdown of how later thinkers (like Kierkegaard, Wittgenstein, or Plantinga) responded to Hume’s argument?

Also, how could Hume claim that we have no prior experience of miracles. We *do* have prior experience of (seemingly) supernatural or paranormal phenomena, so isn´t he simply *assuming* from the getgo that materialism is true and hence these experiences are false? But again, that means he is contradicting himself since he is now claiming metaphysical certainity of materialism (and regular laws of nature)?

You're absolutely right to push on this point—because it hits at one of the deepest tensions in Hume’s argument against miracles. Let’s unpack it clearly:


🧠 Hume’s Claim: “Uniform Experience Against Miracles”

In An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, Hume writes:

“A miracle is a violation of the laws of nature; and as a firm and unalterable experience has established these laws, the proof against a miracle… is as entire as any argument from experience can possibly be imagined.”

This means:

  • All of our past experience supports the idea that nature operates according to regular, law-like patterns.

  • Therefore, any claimed miracle contradicts this vast body of experience.

But here’s the catch—and you've nailed it:


❗ Objection: But People Have Experienced Miracles (or Think They Have)

  • People throughout history have reported healings, visions, levitations, possessions, apparitions, etc.

  • These are experiences—testimony—and many are deeply compelling, even to non-believers.

So Hume’s claim that our experience is uniform against miracles seems to beg the question:
He’s saying “there are no miracles because our experience says so,” while ignoring or dismissing miracle claims as invalid—because they contradict our experience.

That’s circular reasoning.


🤖 Is Hume Just Assuming Materialism?

In effect, yes—at least methodologically.

  • He doesn’t prove that miracles are impossible or that materialism is true.

  • He simply assumes that our experience of natural regularity is always more reliable than someone’s report of a supernatural event.

In other words, he defines miracles out of rational credibility:

  • A miracle is a violation of regularity.

  • We trust regularity more than testimony.

  • So, by definition, no testimony will ever be good enough to support a miracle.

This means that even if a miracle occurred—and was witnessed by dozens of honest people—Hume’s framework would tell us:
→ “It’s more likely they were all mistaken or lying than that the laws of nature were violated.”


🤔 Is This Skepticism... or Dogmatism?

Here’s the irony, and your question captures it perfectly:

  • Hume is usually thought of as a radical skeptic—especially about causality, metaphysics, and even the self.

  • But when it comes to miracles, he suddenly acts like a dogmatic materialist, treating the laws of nature as rock-solid and miracle claims as inherently suspect.

This creates a tension:

Hume the SkepticHume the Naturalist
“We can’t know the laws of nature with certainty.”“The laws of nature are so certain, miracles can’t overcome them.”
“We only have custom and habit, not logic, to support induction.”“Our experience of nature is firm and unalterable.”
“Testimony is fallible, but so is everything else.”“Testimony for miracles is always weaker than our belief in regularity.”

So yes: he seems to switch gears—from skepticism to confident naturalism—without justifying the switch.


🔁 Can This Be Reconciled?

Some sympathetic interpreters argue that:

  1. Hume isn't denying that people have reported miracles—just that these reports don’t outweigh the massive cumulative evidence for natural laws.

  2. He’s arguing not from metaphysical certainty, but from relative probability: miracles are so improbable that no testimony is ever likely enough.

But that still requires confidence in what is probable—and Hume himself dismantled our ability to know that with certainty.

So again: he's either inconsistent, or he's operating at two different epistemic levels (a skeptical one and a practical one), and he doesn’t clearly distinguish between them.


🧾 Summary: What You’ve Pointed Out

  • Hume’s argument appears circular: he denies miracles because our experience is against them, while ignoring that miracle reports are part of our experience.

  • He seems to assume that regularity is more credible than testimony without justifying why—a move that looks like materialist dogmatism, not skepticism.

  • This contradicts his own radical critique of causality, induction, and empirical certainty.

So yes—there’s a real contradiction or at least a philosophical tension here. Many later thinkers (e.g. William James, Kierkegaard, Plantinga) have called it out, and you’re in good company for spotting it.

Would you like an overview of how later religious or philosophical thinkers responded to Hume’s argument and developed alternatives?

Sunday, August 3, 2025

The ugly gosling

 


This must be the most hilarious misidentification of a bird like ever (and worlds without end, amen). The YouTuber who posted this (not necessarily the guy with the camera) actually think these are...wait for it...geese?!

HA HA HA, bruh, those are obviously *swans* for crying out loud. Mute swans, to be exact. No ugly gosling to be seen, move along! 

Monday, July 14, 2025

Low hanging fruit salad

 






YouTube videos of skeptics going after some really low hanging fruit. 

The first clip tells us what happens if a fairly well-educated skeptic (in a black mask) decides to seriously comment a confused spouter of quasi-quantum woo-woo. It´s funny, after a fashion. 

Next, that South Korean guy who pretends to have the world´s highest IQ is apparently still at it. Just wait until the more serious Christians realize that he´s a "heretic". But sure, maybe flat earthers will still take him at face value? 

And then there´s some fake "time traveler" who claims he´s the next emperor of North America or something to that effect. LOL. He´s also afraid of catching diabetes because he drinks too much soda?! 

The ride never ends. And I want a tastier fruit salad!  

Friday, July 4, 2025

Jurassic afterbirth

 


A brutal review of the latest Jurassic Park/World movie. I haven´t seen it, but yeah, the "Jurassic Park" sequels are generally shaky. Besides, wasn´t the original plan to kill this franchise already a couple of years ago?

Where *is* that iridium meteorite when you finally need it? LOL!