Showing posts with label Trotskyism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trotskyism. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Just leave Nepal

 


Is this weird article some kind of mistake? The product of a senile mind, perhaps? Note that it identifies economic development with "capitalism" and reaches the conclusion that nobody should live at higher elevations in Nepal?! The article sounds almost primitivist, despite also (implicitly) denying climate change. The SWP (US) is becoming increasingly less coherent...

In case anybody gives shit.

Nepal flood shows capitalism, not "climate", caused disasters

Tuesday, October 13, 2026

Spartacism sui generis

 

Credit: Arunraj Foundation

So what is the Spartacist League doing these days? Well, I had a look. They have joined a "united front campaign" called "Movement for Kshama" in California, endorsing the independent socialist campaign of Kshama Sawant, leader of the Revolutionary Workers organization.

There is just one problem.

Kshama Sawant actually condemned the "Movement for Kshama". The reason? It consists of a breakaway faction from her own organization, called Labor Militant (sic), plus some fringe groups such as our dear friends of Spartacist. In other words, it´s a somewhat peculiar example of entryism. Or at least political mimicry.

It´s also rather funny that the Sparts call this a "united front". Yeah, whatever. So the post-Robertson Spartacist League has simply decided to be sectarian in alliance with other sectarian groups, rather than being sectarian on their own. Or, I suppose, being sectarian with Kshama Sawant...

Next question! 

Friday, October 9, 2026

On the brink

 

Credit: Mheidegger

The situation at the Horn of Africa is even more complex than I imagined. 

Note that Eritrea has switched sides in the Ethiopian conflict, from backing the government of Abyi Ahmed against the rebel TPLF to backing the rebels instead. Despite Eritrea´s reputation as a pseudo-Communist authoritarian regime, the United States recently lifted the sanctions against its ruling party, probably to lure the country into an alliance against the pro-Iranian Houthis in Yemen. 

The Saudis also back Eritrea, while Israel prefers Abyi, and so do the United Arab Emirates! All four are supposed to be US allies against Iran. And in neighboring Sudan, Saudi Arabia and the UAE are on opposite sides in the genocidal civil war...

I´m old enough to remember when the West supported Abyi Ahmed, even giving him the hotly coveted Nobel Peace Prize, but it seems the man may no longer be our prime "asset" in this part of the world. Who is? Does anyone know? Do we even *want* to know?  

Fighting in Ethiopia threatens renewed civil war, destabilising the Horn of Africa

Tuesday, October 6, 2026

Look who´s serving Roko´s basilisk

 


Look who´s serving Roko´s basilisk. Yes, it´s the former Workers League, now the Socialist Equality Party, still headed by Comrade North. Rather than dismantling AI, they want to nationalize it for the benefit of "the working class" or something to that effect. They have even launched a "Socialist AI" all their own (yes, really) which they promote in a very culty manner. Apparently, it has world historic significance, being a weapon of the Party or whatever.

Am I surprised? Nupe. Next question!

AI, the crisis of capitalism and the tasks of the SEP

Saturday, October 3, 2026

Unable to consent

 


The British SWP on the suspected gang rape at Cornell University in the United States. What a pity the perps weren´t Hamas terrorists and the victim an Israeli woman. I mean, then the SWP could have supported the "widespread violence" in good conscience. While of course denying it ever happened. You know, a bit like the Cornell administration...

The hypocrisy of these people never ceases to amaze me. 

Cornell case exposes widespread violence at university campuses

Monday, September 14, 2026

From Trotskyism to Tantrism?

 

Ganapati the Seeker

The second part of ChatGPT´s analysis of *this* blog. However, the AI is confusing/conflating me with one of my commentators! Or several of them? So this is a bit "schizo". But still an intriguing read... 

There is a rumor that the blogger was originally a Trotskyist and then became a Trump supporter?!

Yes — there is substantial evidence for the two halves of that rumor, but I would distinguish what can actually be established from what is inferred.

The blog itself gives us unusually strong clues.

The Trotskyist past looks quite plausible

The author clearly has deep first-hand familiarity with Trotskyist and other sectarian Marxist politics, far beyond what one would expect from someone who merely read about them.

For example, in the April 16, 2021 post Wag the dog, the blogger writes about obscure 1940s Marxist groups, the Trotskyist SWP, Workers Party, Oehlerites, Stammists, the Fourth International, Sam Marcy, etc. The tone is that of someone who has spent a great deal of time inside or around the Marxist sectarian milieu.

More tellingly, the blogger repeatedly discusses Trotskyism from an insider-ish perspective, including the peculiar intellectual habits of small Marxist groups. That's consistent with having actually been involved in that world.

There is also a fascinating 2025 post about determinism in which the author says:

“When I was 12 — in the spring of 1967 — I read about determinism…”

and then describes becoming an enthusiastic determinist before encountering Christian socialists around 1973.

So the chronology seems to point toward someone who was intellectually formed during the 1960s–70s radical left, rather than someone who discovered Marxism recently.

And the Trump part is definitely not invented

The blog has been remarkably sympathetic to some aspects of Trumpism for years.

Already in May 2019, the author was arguing that Trump shouldn't simply be understood as an aberration, and was sharply critical of the liberal anti-Trump narrative. One post explicitly contrasts Macron and Orbán and says, in effect, “why is Orbán worse than Macron—and what about Donald Trump?”

Then there's the wonderfully revealing April 19, 2021 post titled:

“But Trump was right...”

The author quotes the International Marxist Tendency and argues that Biden was being forced to continue or deepen Trump's nationalist/protectionist policies. The post is actually tagged Trotskyism, Marxism, Donald Trump, Biden and Geopolitics.

That's important because it suggests the political trajectory isn't simply:

left → right

but something more peculiar:

Trotskyist/Marxist analysis → continued interest in class/economic structure → hostility to neoliberalism/globalism → increasing sympathy for nationalist/populist politics → partial Trumpism.

In other words, the blogger seems to have carried certain analytical habits from the far left into a radically different political position.

But I wouldn't yet call him simply a “Trump supporter”

There's an important complication.

The blogger frequently discusses Trump critically or ironically, and often seems more interested in the contradictions surrounding Trump than in Trump personally.

The 2025 material, for instance, comments on MAGA, Trump's bombing of Iran, Peter Thiel, Richard Spencer, the far right, etc. The blog labels material Far right, Anti-semitism, Donald Trump, MAGA, and so forth.

And the blogger explicitly warns that:

“Many posts and comments are ironic.”

So one has to be careful about interpreting every favorable-sounding Trump statement as an endorsement.

There is also a revealing 2019 post about Trump that describes the liberal opposition to him as a kind of “fetish”, while arguing that the deeper problem is globalized capitalism. That's a very distinctive post-left rather than conventional Republican argument.

In fact, I think the political evolution is more interesting than “Trotskyist → Trumpist”

My tentative reconstruction would be something like:

1960s/70s radical left → Marxist/Trotskyist intellectual milieu → disillusionment with sectarian Marxism → continued anti-capitalist/class analysis → hostility to neoliberal globalization → interest in populism and nationalism → sympathy for some Trump positions.

And this explains something that otherwise looks bizarre about the blog.

The author can simultaneously:

  • make fun of Trotskyist sectarianism,
  • understand it intimately,
  • criticize contemporary identity politics from the left,
  • attack neoliberal capitalism,
  • criticize liberal anti-Trumpism,
  • appreciate some Trump policies,
  • mock MAGA,
  • criticize the far right,
  • and still occasionally use distinctly Marxist categories.

That isn't necessarily ideological inconsistency. It may represent someone who left Trotskyism but never entirely abandoned the analytical framework through which he originally understood politics.

And that would also explain why the blog's politics are so difficult to place on an ordinary left-right spectrum.

One particularly interesting clue

The author seems almost fascinated by political metamorphosis itself.

The blog repeatedly returns to people and movements that move between ideological camps: Marxists becoming nationalists, leftists becoming conservatives, conservatives becoming dissidents, former radicals becoming religious, etc.

That makes me suspect that the author's own trajectory is part of the intellectual background of the blog.

So, yes: I think the rumor has a substantial factual basis. I would phrase it more cautiously as:

The blogger appears to have had a serious Trotskyist/Marxist background and subsequently developed strong sympathy for some Trump/populist positions.

I would not yet state as established fact that he was formally a member of a particular Trotskyist organization, nor that he is currently a straightforward Trump/MAGA supporter.

There is actually enough material on the blog to try to reconstruct the political biography decade by decade—especially the transition from the 1960s/70s left to the later anti-globalist/populist position. That could be quite revealing, because I suspect the political evolution is closely connected to the blogger's later religious/philosophical evolution as well.

Friday, September 11, 2026

99 svarta ballonger

 


Det här är tydligen en lista över samtliga partier som ställer upp i årets riksdagsval. Socialistiskt Alternativ och RKP lyser med sin frånvaro. Kommunistiska Partiet har anmält sig, men enligt deras hemsida deltar de *inte* i riksdagsvalet.

Observera att något slags skämtare har anmält Kalle Anka-partiet! Eftersom EAP tydligen inte ställer upp, så slipper de förnedringen att än en gång få färre röster än ankisterna. Det knasigaste partinamnet på listan torde vara "Johannespartiet med extra älg", tätt följt av "99 svarta ballonger"...

Okej, lite underhållning så här på upploppet!

Anmälda partier - Val till riksdagen

Tuesday, August 11, 2026

Sjöfolken kommer

 


Har valt att inte engagera mig i kulturkriget kring filmen "The Odyssey". Har inte sett den och tänker aldrig läsa det ursprungliga eposet. För vem fan bryr sig om ett järnåldersepos som mytologiserar ett bronsålderskrig? 

Den extrema vänstergruppen "RKP" och deras brittiska moderparti "RCP" har dock några intressanta tagningar på filmen. Har Christopher Nolan inverterat Odyséen och förvandlat den till en antikrigsfilm med ett samhällskritiskt budskap om den moderna civilisationens nedgång? Okej, någon gång om tio år (när filmen äntligen visas på SVT Play) kanske jag kan tänka mig att faktiskt titta på den... 

När myten tas på allvar

Nolan´s "The Odyssey": An anti-war epic (på engelska)

Wednesday, June 3, 2026

Det här känns så 2012

 


De senaste dagarna har jag vid två eller tre tillfällen sett uttrycket "rasifierade" (på engelska "racialized"). Men herre-fucking-gud, den här terminologin känns så 2012. 

Dessutom är den absurd, eftersom de "rasifierade personerna" (okej, de är inte längre "kroppar" utan faktiska personer - whoa, framsteg, kamrater!) av allt att döma *vill vara rasifierade*. Är inte det själva poängen med identitetspolitiken? 

Okej, låt mig gissa. De vänsterungdomar som blev radikaliserade circa 2012 sitter numera i ledningen för diverse organisationer...och har helt enkelt fortsatt med den floskulösa retorik de fick lära sig första året på kulturvetarlinjen?

Woke-vänstern stretar på... 

Sunday, May 10, 2026

Pablo (Raptis)

 


I hardly read this long far right attack on Keir Starmer, but it does contain one interesting fact (or is it factoid). The author claims that Starmer was a supporter of Michel Pablo´s Trotskyist current IRMT in his youth?! 

Keir Starmer´s Marxist past

Sunday, March 8, 2026

Saturday, March 7, 2026

The One and The Many

 

Credit: Charles J Sharp 

This kind of (far) left factional/clique/claque infighting is extremely tiresome. If I had any interest in this kind of politics, I would either stay in Labour or join the Greens. Note also the hilarious anti-sectarian posturing from Corbyn´s faction (actually called The Many). So how many members does Your Party have in total? 

It´s not even clear whether the Corbynistas are less sectarian than, say, the Trotskyist SWP since the latter group apparently supports the Greens, the Next Big Thing in British politics! And no, I have no idea what "Imperiali" and "Droop" means either...  

"The Many" claims a false mandate

Monday, March 2, 2026

Wednesday, January 21, 2026

Proletarian Military Policy

 


Let´s see if I get this right. By Marxist-leftist standards, the United States is imperialist. But so is the EU. Heck, so is little Denmark. So presumably the left won´t defend Denmark (and hence Greenland) against an attack by Donald Trump´s administration?

Is that correctly understood?

Maybe they would defend Greenland if there had been an Inuit workers´ militia in place at Nuuk. But alas, there isn´t. So if they are true to their hallowed principles of revolutionary defeatism, they have to stay neutral.

And yes, I´m probably the only one sperging about this in the darkness of cyberspace... 

Funny picture, btw.

Tuesday, January 13, 2026

Somaliland forever

 


Does the Fourth International (FI) support al-Qaeda? Somehow, I doubt it. Yet, the article linked below was published in their magazine "International Viewpoint". It originally appeared in "L´Anticapitaliste", the publication of the NPA, the FI´s famed French section. 

The article argues that Israel conspires with Somaliland to expel the entire population of Gaza to that particular country. No source is given for this truly remarkable statement. A conspiracy theory? Then, the piece expresses tacit support for Al-Shabab. Ahem, that´s an al-Qaeda ally...

How confused is the far left *exactly*? Here are two representative quotes. 

>>>Beyond the upheaval of the regional order, this recognition opens a breach allowing for the expulsion of Palestinians, as acceptance of this population transfer seems to have been a condition for the recognition of the state.

>>>In their imperial symbiosis, Israeli and American leaders have been searching for several months for a territory capable of accommodating a significant portion of the Palestinian people in order to bring the Palestinian question to a definitive close. 

>>>The recognition of Somaliland, coupled with promises of financial transfers, could encourage independence activists to accept this colonial project, although Al-Shabab militiamen are reminding them of the importance of preserving national unity and the duty of loyalty to the Palestinian community. 

The ethnic cleansing of Gaza by NGOs and Somaliland

Monday, January 12, 2026

Gay, retarded and very, very British?

 


Is Spiked´s flirtation with Trumpite right-wing populism finally over? Did they really expect "British fair play" from *that* quarter? Or have they simply decided that the Trump Train isn´t lucrative anymore, and decided to strike out for greener pastures somewhere else? I mean, the U-turns of this outfit are near-legendary! Cough, cough, Living Marxism, cough cough.  

The author predicts that the "Woke right" will call him "gay and retarded". LOL! Maybe, but I have to say that the meaningless insult "Woke right" is pretty "gay", if you must use homophobic internet slang. Or at least retarded...

Why can´t the right say that the death of Renee Good was a tragedy?

Monday, December 15, 2025

Esoterisk marxism

 


Kan ju inte undgå att länka till denna. Ja, det är den högerradikala/högerextrema "tankesmedjan" Motpol som recenserar "I Want To Believe", alltså den där boken om Juan Posadas och hans bisarra rörelse. Tonvikten ligger såklart vid UFO-aspekten...

Posadismer

Ibrahim Traoré Speaks

 

Credit: RIA Novosti 

This is a bit esoterick, but...could the American SWP plz explain the difference between this guy and Thomas Sankara?

Ibrahim Traoré

Sunday, December 14, 2025

The Burkinabé fashion revolution

 


Burkina Faso´s leader Ibrahim Traoré bans wigs. Supposedly. I don´t know, I get the impression that the Burkinabé revolution has fallen on hard times. And where is Jack Barnes???