The blog to end all blogs. Reviews and comments about all and everything. This blog is NOT affiliated with YouTube, Wikipedia, Microsoft Bing, Gemini, ChatGPT or any commercial vendor! Links don´t imply endorsement. Many posts and comments are ironic. The blogger is not responsible for comments made by others. The languages used are English and Swedish. Content warning: Essentially everything.
Showing posts with label Orthodox Church. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Orthodox Church. Show all posts
I´m not a "joiner", but I sometimes feel *somewhat* frustrated by the fact that there doesn´t seem to be any religion (or concrete religious movement/organization) I can join. I simply know too much.
As a thought-experiment, I asked ChatGPT to give me recommendations. For rather obvious reasons, the system mostly recommended me to join groups I recently prompted it to write about: Shri Vaishnavism, Pure Land Buddhism, or perhaps some "safe" form of Shaktism (assuming it even exists). But on one point, ChatGPT did "think for itself": it proposed Christianity, perhaps the Eastern Orthodox Church.
Gemini was downright funny. It actually recommended me *not* to join any group, but rather strike out on my own, since I seem so eclectic! :D
At least nobody in AI-Land think I´m a Zen Buddhist anymore...
>>>ROCA (aka Russian Orthodox Church Abroad) is another way to say ROCOR, Russian Orthodox Church outside Russia. When you say you’re ROCA/ROCOR or “continuing ROCA/ROCOR,” there’s already an idea that one has about what this entails. The idea one would naturally be inclined towards is the canonical ROCOR (or what TOs commonly refer to as “ROCOR-MP”) presently under Met. Nicholas.
>>>If someone is a TO priest in a “ROCA/ROCOR” offshoot splinter group, when asked what his jurisdiction is, should specify rather than simply saying “ROCA/ROCOR” or “continuing ROCA/ROCOR” lest they mislead the simple faithful into believing his jurisdiction falls somewhere under the First-Hierarch Met. Nicholas. ROCANA folk even self-designate themselves as being ROCANA. To say otherwise to someone who’s unaware of the 20+ ROCA/ROCOR splinter groups is to deliberately conceal information. That’s snake behavior.
Some kind of fundamentalist Eastern Orthodox group. Apparently, nobody was in communion with heretics before December 7, 1965. Or something. Ooookay...
I assumed Colorado was a big desert or something but naaah, a lot of snow in this one. And yes, it´s the adorable religious sasquatch Brother Nathanael. The sighting is about 14 years old. It will never ever be debunked!
Some gossip about True Orthodoxy, Old Calendarism and such. The situation is even worse than I expected. How many splits do these guys have *exactly*? Hundreds? Note also their absurd contradictions, such as Old Calendarists accepting consecration from supposedly "graceless" New Calendarists, ecumenism while condemning ecumenism, et cetera. Schism begets schizos, it seems. Nothing about Brother Nathanael, though.
Brother Nathanael again. A Jew who converted to the Russian Orthodox Church stands somewhere in Idaho complaining about multi-culturalism and immigration, oooookay...
Here is a short clip (just nine minutes) featuring Brother Nathanael, the religious sasquatch mentioned in my previous blog post. He sounds surprisingly sober here, LOL. Well, kind of.
If you like quasi-religious gossip (mostly about Orthodox and Catholic sectarian splinter groups), the first two hours (or so) of this video might rock your world.
"Brother Nathanael" is apparently a local profile & kook extraordinaire in northern Idaho and Spokane. Many people there refer to him as a "religious sasquatch" and jokingly call his visits into town "Brother Nathanael sightings". His latest contretemps are detailed in this podcast, hosted by an Orthobro. The guest is presumably affiliated with the SSPX, which Nathanael recently tried to join. Nathanael´s obsession with a Belarusian honeypot is especially funny.
Less entertaining is the guy´s anti-Semitism...since he´s really ethnically Jewish?! At one point, an SSPX-affiliated priest jokingly asked an Orthodox Jewish rabbi if they could *please* take Nathanael back. The rabbi refused...
And a paper tiger? A lot of strawmen in this one. Maybe this is a relevant criticism (barely) of certain "official" Communist regimes circa 1960, but it´s hardly a serious criticism of Karl Marx and Frederick Engels. Note also the hypocritical "pie in the sky" message. Endure yer suffering, proles! Nupe, won´t happen, comrade. Or should I call you "citizen"?
"Professor Jiang" is a somewhat peculiar Internet personality who rose to prominence recently. His message seems to be a confused "lowest common denominator" of every on-line conspiracy / alternative theory, which may explain his sudden success.
Unless it´s algorithmic manipulation...
Some conspiracy theorists (!) suspect that Jiang is an asset of the Chinese regime, but Jay Dyer (also a conspiracist) believe it´s more likely that the fake professor is a *Western* influence agent. Indeed, he was arrested by the Chinese authorities at one point and extradited from the country! For unclear reasons, he was later allowed back, which obviously gave rise to rumors that he must be secretely working for the CCP or be a double agent.
I don´t claim to know who Jiang is, except that he sounds frankly uninteresting even for a supposed fringey!
Orthodox bad boy Jay Dyer calls out the SSPX (or as he jokingly calls them: Ssss-pksss), who were recently excommunicated from the Catholic Church. The SSPX faithful presumably want the Orthodox to submit to Rome, but they don´t seem willing to submit themselves...
Dyer was a supporter of the SSPX for a number of years and his video contains some funny gossip about the society. Are we to believe Dyer, the SSPX is teeming with crypto-Nazis, barely closeted homosexuals and kooks in general. At one point, our man emphasizes that no gay priest ever touched his butt?! Alcoholism is another rampant problem. One SSPX priest had a private collection of German Nazi memorabilia which he treated in an almost sacramental manner. Dyer also believes that the society is theologically heterodox compared to mainstream conservative Catholicism, perhaps in a Jansenist and Gallican direction.
His main argument against the Society of Saint Pius X, however, is their refusal to consistently obey the papacy. Dyer argues at length that according to both Catholic theology and canon law, Catholics are duty bound to follow "the First See" at Rome *on all issues*. Yet, the SSPX picks and chooses which decisions of Rome they will follow, and hence acts exactly like the "modernists" they are condemning!
This is something I noticed, too. The SSPX do next level "lawyering" in order to stay inside the Catholic Church. For instance, they pretend to recognize the Second Vatican Council, but argue that its decisions aren´t binding (cuz reasons blah blah).
In case you are interested in this latest occasion for scandal...
Here is our man Formscapes again. I commented on "Mr Breakfast" and one of his videos about the GenZ revival before.
>>>Recently (ish) the channel "religion for breakfast" released a video which addressed the "zoomer religious revival" phenomenon. In the video, Mr Breakfast argues that this phenomenon isn't actually occurring, and that the headlines claiming otherwise are all misleading, and presents a decent pile of survey/statistical data which seems to suggest that no such revival is happening.
>>>This, my friends, is a great example of why quantifiable data should never be trusted more than your own eyeballs. Source; my eyeballs. What the statistical data does show is that there had been a very pronounced downward trend in religiosity over the past few decades, and that this downward trend seems to be coming to a halt. But, argues Mr Breakfast, this halt of a downward trend is not a "revival" because there has not been an uptick in church attendance, professed religiosity, conversions, etc...
>>>Statistical data is, I ven under the best of circumstances, a sawed-off shotgun among epistemological tools, due to the fact that it is extremely reductive and abstract, and - significantly - because the extent of this glossing is usually not fully clear to people.
>>>In this case, what those numbers aren't accounting for is the fact that not all human beings are equal in terms of cultural influence. Among any generation of people, you are going to have a very large majority of people who are just kind of "going with the vibe", and a very small minority of people who are standing on the razor's edge between present and future. The latter are what the kids these days refer to as "main character energy", so I'm told.
>>>So if you want to understand the direction a given zeitgeist is headed in, you shouldn't be taking of surveys of everyone as though everyone were equal. You need to look to the "main character energy" people and see what they are doing, bc in very short order, the "just going with the vibe" people will be following along with the trail being cleared by the former.
>>>When I - a millennial - was in my late teens and early twenties, all of us "main character" kids were into things like Marxism, new atheism and postmodernism. No statistical study performed in 2008 would have predicted that in 15 years, those ideas would have leaked into every aspect of pop culture. But anyone paying attention could have told you that, bc they could see with their own eyeballs that those were the topics of interest to all of the people of that generation who were undoubtedly going to become novelists, opinion piece writers, screenplay writers and academics in the coming decades.
>>>The current religious revival is like that. Look at the people who are suddenly converting to Orthodoxy and Catholicism. They aren't the "go with the vibes" kids. They are the cerebral, autistic nerds who will be novelists, opinion havers, screenplay writers, etc in the next decade or two.
>>>Now to be clear, I don't think that this is a good thing - for reasons I'll be getting into in my next unscripted rant video, so stay tuned for that - but it is definitely happening, and that is in fact what the statistical data shows if you have eyeballs with which to see what the statistical data is actually about.
>>>Nothing is Hidden™️