Showing posts with label Foraminifera. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Foraminifera. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 5, 2018

Caveat emptor



"Qualitative observations on recent Foraminifera tests with emphasis on the Eastern Pacific" is the impossibly long title of a four-volume mastodon work, signed Irene McCulloch. She compiled it with the help of the heroic captain G. Allan Hancock onboard the Velero IV. For several years, this science vessel was cruising the world's oceans searching for valuable specimens of forams. However, it seems that not everything is well on the foram front, since McCulloch complains about "lack of space, lack of a budget and lack of all kinds of assistance". But she did manage to fill four extensive hardcover books with information, didn't she? Incidentally, I really hope that Amazon's third party seller carries all 4 volumes in one set, since you're going to need them all, if at all interested in foraminiferans. The black-and-white photographic plates are in volume IV, and I suppose the list of research "stations" (the exact places in the ocean where the forams were collected) is also in that volume, since I couldn't find it in volume I.

Buyer, beware!

The rest of us honestly don't know what to say...

Wednesday, July 25, 2018

Neo-Haeckelian protistology



"Handbook of Protoctista" is an extensive, scientific reference work on micro-organisms. Lynn Margulis is one of the editors. The subtitle is rather extensive: "The structure, cultivation, habitats and life histories of the Eukaryotic microorganisms and their descendants exclusive of animals, plants and fungi. A guide to the algae, ciliates, foraminifera, sporozoa, water moulds, slime moulds and the other protoctists".

Why even write a review, with this presentation?

The following statement from the introduction by Lewis Thomas is also worth quoting: "Just a few years back, this book would have seemed to most readers trained in either medicine or biology nothing more than an arcane compendium of nature's most outlandish oddities, queer single cells of primary interest only to the most specialized of specialists". Well, at least he's honest! I suppose doing research on chimpanzees or mountain gorillas is better for your pay check, too. What turned the scientific community to a more pro-protoctistan position isn't entirely clear, but it sounds as if evolutionary theory has something to do with it. Today, Protoctista are regarded as our distant parents. Amen and amen?

When this book was published, about 100,000 species of protoctists were known to science. As behoves a micro-organism, they can be encountered pretty much anywhere. When studying the hypertrophied intestines of an East African rhinoceros, W. Van Hoven discovered a new world of symbiotic eukaryotes using scanning electron microscopy. Meanwhile, a wood-ingesting termite may contain as many as thirty different protist species. No surprise there.

The editors of "Handbook of Protoctista" don't consider their objects of study to be single-celled plants or animals, "anymore than humans are shell-less multicellular amebas". An ironic statement, given the claim that protoctists are our parents. Be that as it may, Lynn Margulis and her colleagues wanted to establish the Protoctista not only as an independent field of study, but also as a "kingdom" in its own right, alongside the "kingdoms" of animals, plants and fungi. They also reject classification schemes of algae based on colour. No more talk about red or green algae, please! At one point, the authors call their approach Neo-Haeckelian protistology.

The rest of the book is an extravagant super-encyclopaedia. The entries are divided into sections dealing with Habitat and Ecology, Characterization and Recognition, Maintenance and Cultivation, Evolutionary History and References. There is also an extensive glossary. The text is heavy, but "Handbook of Protoctista" is probably a must for advanced students who want to walk in the footsteps of Margulis.