Saturday, November 21, 2026

India is Karbala, Karbala is India

 

Imam Husayn

Will check the sources for this when my web connection stops malfunctioning, but in the meantime, heeeere we go! From ChatGPT.

Are there any examples of Hindus participating in Muslim festivals or Muslim worship?

Yes. And there are some remarkably strong examples. In fact, Hindu participation in Muslim religious observances has a particularly long history in South Asia, especially in the worship of Sufi saints and the Shia commemoration of Muharram.

Some Hindus have not merely attended Muslim festivals socially: they have made vows to Muslim saints, observed fasts, attended mourning assemblies, helped construct ritual objects and participated in devotional ceremonies.

I would distinguish three forms of participation.

1. Hindus participating in Muharram

This is probably the most striking historical example.

Muharram commemorates the martyrdom of Imam Husayn, grandson of the Prophet Muhammad, at Karbala in 680 CE. Its tenth day, Ashura, is especially important in Shia Islam.

Historically, Hindus participated in Muharram in several parts of India:

  • Lucknow: Hindu households attended Shia mourning assemblies (majalis) and participated in mourning rituals (matam).

  • Hyderabad: Hindus participated in processions carrying tazias, symbolic replicas of Imam Husayn's mausoleum.

  • Delhi: Hindu participants took part in certain Muharram processions and contributed food to participants.

  • Central India: Some Hindu families constructed their own tazias, observed fasting and made vows in connection with Imam Husayn.

A particularly fascinating historical account describes a Hindu cook employed by the British traveller Fanny Parkes who spent considerable money constructing a cenotaph for Imam Husayn, performed the Muharram rites, and subsequently buried the cenotaph with offerings.

This was not simply social participation. Some Hindus evidently regarded Husayn as a sacred protector or intercessor.

2. Hindus visiting Sufi shrines and participating in urs

This is probably the most widespread form of Hindu participation in Muslim devotional life.

An urs is the annual commemoration of a Sufi saint's death, understood in Sufi traditions as the saint's union with God. It commonly includes prayers, devotional music (qawwali), offerings, processions and communal meals.

Hindus visit many such shrines, sometimes making vows (mannat) and offering a chadar (ceremonial cloth) at the tomb.

Some notable examples:

  • Ajmer Sharif Dargah: The shrine of Khwaja Muinuddin Chishti attracts Hindu as well as Muslim pilgrims. Hindu visitors make offerings and seek blessings.

  • Deva Sharif: Hindu disciples of the Sufi saint Haji Waris Ali Shah participate in the shrine's devotional culture. Hindus have also traditionally joined Muslims in playing Holi at the shrine.

  • Asmal Pir, Gujarat: In one reported village tradition, the entire Hindu population gathers annually at the saint's dargah for his urs, offering cloths and flags, contributing food and eating together.

The last example is especially significant: the participants are not simply attending a public fair. They are making offerings at a Muslim saint's shrine.

3. Hindus observing Ramadan fasts

There are documented examples of Hindus observing roza (the Ramadan fast), particularly in Rajasthan.

A 2018 Times of India report describes Hindu Meghwal villagers in the Barmer and Jaisalmer districts who fast during Ramadan because of their devotion to Pir Pithora, a saint whose shrine is in Sindh, Pakistan.

The practice is associated with Hindu families who regard Pir Pithora as a sacred protector. Some observe Ramadan fasting alongside their Muslim neighbours.

This is particularly interesting because fasting is not merely a social activity: it is a religious discipline adopted from Islamic practice.

4. Hindus participating in Eid celebrations

There are many examples of Hindu neighbours joining Eid celebrations, exchanging sweets, visiting Muslim homes and participating in communal meals.

For example, in Agra in 2021, Hindus and Muslims celebrated Eid al-Adha together, with members of both communities exchanging greetings and embracing one another.

The Pew Research Center's large survey of Indian religious life found that about 7% of Hindus said they participated in Eid celebrations. This is less common than Muslim participation in Hindu festivals, but it is not negligible.

I would distinguish this from participating in the actual Islamic prayer (salat). The evidence for Hindus attending Eid festivities is much stronger than evidence of Hindus joining the congregational Muslim prayer as worshippers.

5. The Hussaini Brahmins: a particularly fascinating tradition

The Hussaini Brahmins are a particularly interesting example of a Hindu community with a historical devotional connection to Imam Husayn.

They are associated with traditions linking their ancestors to the Battle of Karbala. Some members have maintained a special reverence for Husayn and participate in Muharram commemorations.

The historical details of their origin are disputed, and it would be misleading to treat all Hussaini Brahmins as following identical practices. Nevertheless, their traditions demonstrate how Hindu and Shia Muslim religious memories have sometimes become intertwined.

6. A comparison of the different forms of participation

Muslim religious observance

Hindu participation

Muharram

Fasting, mourning, tazia-making, processions and devotional acts

Sufi urs

Offerings, vows, shrine visits and devotional music

Ramadan

Observing the fast and participating in iftar

Eid

Social celebrations, meals and exchanging greetings

Sufi shrine worship

Seeking blessings and protection from Muslim saints

One particularly important distinction: the Muharram and Sufi shrine examples sometimes involve genuine religious devotion, not simply intercommunal friendship. Some Hindus have regarded Imam Husayn or a Sufi saint as a source of divine protection and blessing while continuing to identify as Hindus.

There is also a contemporary example worth mentioning: in Karachi, Pakistan, the Associated Press reported in 2026 on Hindu families who attend Shia congregations, pray, participate in mourning rituals and construct tazias for Ashura. One man, Raju Rathore, has continued this practice for approximately 45 years, fulfilling a vow made by his mother.

That is perhaps the clearest modern counterpart to the Bhandarkata Kali Puja story you asked about earlier: in both cases, a family or community maintains a devotional relationship with a religious tradition different from its own.

The Kali situation is worse than you think

 


I can´t access the source article for this due to some temporary Internet glitch, but here is ChatGPT´s exegesis of the situation. This must be the ultimate Xian fundamentalist nightmare: Muslims worshipping Kali?!

[...]

The Bhandarkata example is unusually striking because it appears to involve a Muslim-majority village whose Muslim residents themselves organise the annual Kali Puja, rather than merely attending a Hindu festival organised by Hindus.

There are two useful sources: a contemporary newspaper report from 2002 and a later field-study article by Munshi Md. Sahebur Rahim, a research scholar at the University of Burdwan.

1. The story of Karim Sheikh

The Telegraph published a report on 3 November 2002 entitled “Minority role in Kali puja”.

According to the report:

  • The village is called Bhanrkata (also spelled Bhandarkata), in the Mohammad Bazar area of Birbhum district, West Bengal.

  • It had approximately 8,000 inhabitants, around 75% of whom were Muslims at the time.

  • The Kali Puja had reportedly been taking place for about a century.

  • Its origin was attributed to a Muslim villager named Karim Sheikh, who experienced a dream in which he was directed towards the goddess.

  • The following morning, he reportedly discovered a Kali image in his granary.

The story is particularly interesting because Karim Sheikh apparently did not perform the puja himself. According to a village elder quoted in the article, he felt that, as a Muslim, he could not personally conduct the Hindu ritual. Instead, he asked a local traditional physician, Dulu Debangsi, to take responsibility for it.

Karim also arranged for agricultural land to be endowed to the goddess. The income from its paddy harvest subsequently financed the annual celebration.

Telegraph India

2. What the festival looks like

The 2002 report provides a few further details:

  • It was the only Kali Puja in the village.

  • Muslim residents made the arrangements and supervised the ceremony.

  • Muslim artisans had been making the Kali image for three generations.

  • The goddess was represented as Bama Kali (Vāmā Kālī), with her left foot placed forward.

  • The celebration included traditional drumming and a village fair.

    Telegraph India

The artisan mentioned in the report was Dulal Sheikh, from the neighbouring village of Madian.

3. Is this an isolated story?

Apparently not entirely.

A March 2026 article in the Bengali research journal Atmadeep, titled A Field Study-Based Analysis of Hindu-Muslim Joint Religious Worship and Votive Practices in Rarh Bengal, also mentions Bhandarkata.

Its author, Munshi Md. Sahebur Rahim, identifies the Kali Puja as an example of a Hindu religious celebration organised by the Muslim community. The article also documents other shared practices in Birbhum and neighbouring districts, including Muslim offerings to Dharmaraj Thakur.

The article is useful corroboration, although its publicly accessible abstract does not provide much additional detail about the actual Kali rituals.

4. What did the Muslim participants believe?

This is where we need to be careful.

The available reporting does not establish whether the Muslim organisers:

  1. Personally believed Kali was a divine being.

  2. Believed that Kali could grant protection or blessings, while retaining an Islamic religious identity.

  3. Regarded the festival primarily as a village tradition inherited from their ancestors.

  4. Held a mixture of these attitudes.

The story of Karim Sheikh's dream suggests that the original tradition may have involved a genuinely devotional relationship with the goddess. But it is an oral account reported by a village elder, not a first-person testimony from Karim.

Likewise, the fact that Muslim artisans made the image does not, by itself, prove that they worshipped it.

5. Why I find this example particularly interesting

It illustrates a form of religious coexistence that is more intimate than simply attending one another's festivals.

The Muslim community appears to have assumed responsibility for maintaining a Hindu goddess's annual festival, including financing, organising and producing her image.

It also raises an interesting theological question: can someone retain a Muslim identity while developing a devotional relationship with a Hindu goddess?

In some South Asian folk-religious environments, the practical answer has historically been yes, even though orthodox Islamic theology generally rejects worship of deities other than Allah.

A qualification: the strongest detailed report I found dates from 2002. The 2026 field-study article confirms that the tradition is still being cited, but I have not found independent evidence establishing exactly how the festival is organised today.

For further reading, the original newspaper report is particularly valuable: The Telegraph, 3 November 2002 – Minority role in Kali puja.

Durga is greater

 


Do Muslims in India worship Durga? Kind of...

Kolkata´s Muslim-organised pujas send out a message of harmony

Muslim women take part in Durga puja

You lack the Gorilla Mindset

 


Super-geek geeks out over some geeky stuff. Apparently, 100 years ago scientists wrongly believed that Australopithecus was a "precocious gorillid" or something to that effect. As opposed to, say, a gutsick gibbon... 

Sure, that *is* kind of funny.

Laxminarayana Besha

 

Credit: Just Kalinga 

If you are a devotee of Jagannath (which I assume you aren´t, so there´s that), today is "Laxminarayana Besha" at the Puri temple. This per the site Just Kalinga. 

And the Lord came to his people

 


Wtf, I love Muslims now...

At this (Hindu) temple in Andhra Pradesh, Muslims line up for blessings

Friday, November 20, 2026

Homo deus

 


A completely stray reflection, so hit me!

Our human species (Homo sapiens) have been "alone" for only 13% of its existence. For 87% of it, we "co-existed" with other human species, for instance the Neanderthals. But somehow, we are unique. Right? Well, I suppose we are. We are unique since we can destroy ourselves with our own technology. No Neanderthal would be stupid enough to hit himself in the head with a stone ax!  

Just unplug it

 


An interesting but also somewhat disturbing video about how to stop an AI apocalypse. It turns out to be easier said than done. The two most obvious options are "Shut down the Internet" and "Nuke the data centers", but both have their problems. The same is true of computer viruses. And what if AI watches videos like this one, thereby anticipating what we might do in advance...? A problem Scott Carney points out himself.

The most promising solution seems to be to write/rewrite the AI code so the technology simply can´t go rogue. But hasn´t that train already left the station? 

There is another possibility: AI can´t "take over the world" unless it also takes control of the physical apparatus IRL surrounding it: mines, plants, power plants, and so on. Can it replace all the human workers needed to actually build the technology? Can it get the necessary energy? Of course, this assumes that rogue AI really wants to run the world and dominate humanity, rather than simply killing it off and go down with it...

This is getting more and more bizarre.   

Världens herre

 

Credit: mavink.com

Titta vad jag har hittat...

Nordisk familjebok (1910): Jagannath

The men of renown

 


An interesting but speculative video about Bigfoot and similar creatures around the world. The content-creator believes that Bigfoot is a relict hominid and thinks he has them figured out. Yes, they are Denisovans. 

My main problem with this speculation / hypothesis is that nobody have been able to catch a Wildman for centuries, which is strange if they live all over the world and even sneak into our suburbs...

Here is my wild(man) speculation: Bigfoot is the ghost of the Denisovans, the original Giants, the men of renown. There.